Home Blog Page 124

Liberia ALERT: Police flog information officer

A group of police officers, acting on the orders of Police Director Chris Massaquoi, flogged Bernard Warity, Deputy Information Minister for Administration in the National Transitional Government of Liberia (NTGL), headed by Charles Gyude Bryant. Warity sustained bruises on his body and was treated at theSt. JosephCatholicHospitalinMonrovia, the capital. Speaking to Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Liberiafrom his hospital bed, Warity explained that the incident occurred at 6:00pm when he was returning from watching a world cup qualifying soccer match between Liberia and Togo.

The police director was also returning from the match when his Toyotajeep allegedly ran into Warity’s car. According to Warity, Mr Massaquoi alighted from his vehicle and ordered his bodyguards to drag and flog him. He claimed that the police director refused to recognize him despite his vehement petitions and desperate attempts to identify himself as a government official. Warity and Massaquoi are both Civil Society representatives on the power-sharing transitional government. Warity is one of two nominees of the Press Union of Liberia (PUL) serving on the NTGL. He was a reporter with the privately owned Star Radio until March 15, 2000, when the dreaded detachment of the national police under Charles Taylor, the Special Operation Division (SOD), raided the premises of the station, scrambled its transmission signals and seized its equipment for allegedly “being agents of people bent on creating security problems in Liberia.” Although the Catholic Church-owned Radio Veritas, which was also shut down the same day, was subsequently allowed to resume broadcasting, Star Radio is yet to come back on air.

The MFWA condemns this manifestation of the vestiges of impunity as was perpetrated under Mr Taylor and calls on the government of President Gyude Bryant to institute a full-scale investigation and sanctioning of Warity’s assailants.

Nigeria ALERT: Journalist in hiding

Oluwole Adeboye, a reporter with the “P.M. News”, a mid-day newspaper in Lagos, fled his Agege home on December 11, 2003 and has since been in hiding. This follows the publication of a story with the reporter’s by-line, about the alleged unprofessional conduct of a police constable, Bamidele Adeola.

According to the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Nigeria, Adeboye had reported that the police officer robbed a commercial motorcycle operator of his GSM mobile phone and money. Following the publication, Constable Adeola was arrested and detained. He was later released; but is said to be facing administrative investigation and possible dismissal.

Babajide Otitoju, editor of the “P.M. News”, told MFWA-Nigeria that several unidentified persons have since been stalking Adeboye for exposing the policeman.

He has also received numerous telephone calls threatening to kill him for daring to expose the policeman. The management of the newspaper therefore advised the reporter to go into hiding until his safety can guaranteed.

MFWA appeals to the Lagos police administration to investigate the alleged threats on the life of journalist Oluwole Adebayo and ensure that he can exercise his legitimate national and universally subscribed rights to life, movement, opinion and expression.

 

Nigeria ALERT: Journalists’ Union protests police intimidation, harassment

The Taraba State Chapter of the Nigerian Union of Journalists (NUJ) on December 11, 2003, accused Police Commissioner Egbechukwu Nwachukwu of masterminding a campaign of intimidation and harassment of journalists in the state.

According to the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Nigeria, a statement signed by the local union secretary, Pojo Nafinji, complained that, following a series of uncomplimentary media reports about the police commissioner, Mr Nwachkwu had publicly threatened to ‘get even’ with journalists who might be involved in any matter brought before the police. Subsequently, when a journalist with the TheNews magazine reported a traffic incident to the police, the commissioner, ironically, ordered the complainant to be charged and sent to court. The magazine’s Tabara State reporter, Ben Adeji, has also recently been twice detained by the police.

The NUJ has, therefore, directed its members to boycott all activities by the state police. The union has also appealed to the Inspector General of Police to withdraw Commissioner Nwachukwu from the state.

Guinea Conakry ALERT: Newspaper banned

State authorities in Guinea have banned the Issue No. 2239, dated 7 – 13 December, 2003, of the “Jeune Afrique l’Intelligent” newspaper.

According to Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Guinea, court officials who effected the seizure order on December 10, refused to give reasons for their action. However, the publication in question had carried an article with the headline, “Witch-hunt in Army”, which the Guinean authorities are said to have been unhappy about. The story documented instances of the current wave of arrests and reprisals against key opposition figures and some army officials perceive to be opposed to the third term presidential ambitions of Gen. Lansana Conté.

In spite of the ban, vendors are reported to be selling photocopies of the newspaper on the sly, in response to popular public demand.

Following rumours about a coup attempt in mid-November 2003, scores of army officials have been arrested and detained by loyalist forces. Prominent among the detainees are Kadr Doubuya, a former army Commandant; Commander Aly Camara, the second in command of the presidential guard; Sikdiki Camara, a senior official at the gendarmerie training school; and Lieutenant Alpha Ousmana Diallo, son of Bubacar Biro Diallo, former speaker of parliament who later became a fierce critic of the president.

The 69 years old Lansana Conté has been in office since 1984 when the army took over power in a coup barely one week after the death of Sékou Touré, the country’s first post-independence president. Gen. Conté stood for and won the country’s first multi-party presidential elections in 1993, amid claims and accusations of ballot rigging and voter intimidation. He was re-elected in 1998, again under highly disputed and generally discredited circumstances.

In November 2001, a nationwide referendum, believed to be largely flawed, amended the constitution to allow the president to run for an unlimited number of five-year terms. Consequently, the ailing former military dictator is standing for the next elections scheduled for December 21, 2003. All the major opposition parties in the country have boycotted the elections because of persistent intimidation and their lack of confidence in the process.

Since March this year, the MFWA has reported at least four incidents of the abuse of the freedom of expression rights of journalists and newspapers for publications related to the second term ambitions of President Conté.

Nigeria ALERT: Magazine, editors face US $7.2 million suit

The Independent Communications Networks Limited, publishers of the “The News” magazine and four of the magazine’s staff, namely, Bayo Onanuga, editor-in-chief, Babafemi Ojodu, managing editor, Bamidele Johnson, deputy editor and Timothy Igandan, reporter, have been dragged to court on a N1 billion (about $US7,246,376) libel suit.

The suit was filed at the Abuja High Court by Dr Amos Adamu, Executive Director of the Organizing Committee (COJA) of the 8th All-Africa Games, “Abuja 2003”.

According to Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Nigeria, Dr. Adamu is claiming the sum of N1 billion as damages for two articles entitled, “The Scandals of COJA” and “Obasanjo’s Family, Atiku and Adamu in N30 Billion Scandal”, published respectively, in the October 27 and November 24, 2003 editions of the magazine. He is also seeking “perpetual injunction restraining the defendants by themselves, their servants and agents from further publication of the said defamatory word or words of the like” against him.

The suit, number FCT/HC/CV/220/2003, filed by Prince Adetokunbo Kayode, counsel, for Dr. Adamu, complained that the two publications ridiculed and disparaged his reputation by portraying him as corrupt and devious in the management of government resources and public funds.

The MFWA is dismayed by the ever-increasing tendency of officials and individuals close to the Obasanjo government, to apply to the law courts, claiming damages for alleged defamation, in sums which, if granted, could have the effect of jeopardizing the very survival of the publications in question.

Barely a fortnight ago, on November 17, Mrs. Stella Obasanjo, wife of President Olusegun Obasanjo, filed a suit at an Abuja High Court seeking a similar sum of N1 billion in “general and exemplary damages” against the same publication. In the suit filed by Dr B. O. Babalakin, Mrs Obasanjo complained that portions of the said publication, which alleged that she got a contract from COJA officials for furnishing of the games village was “based entirely on speculation, unfounded and unsubstantiated allegations.”

That case was adjourned to December 17, 2003.

Obviously, if both reliefs by Mrs Obasanjo and Dr Adamu were granted, they could effectively bankrupt the Independent Communication Network Limited and result in the incarceration of the co-defendants for default. MFWA requests you to, kindly, protest the deteriorating state of media rights and freedom of expression in Nigeria; and in particular, the prohibitive damage claims being sought against the “The News” magazine staff and publishers.

Nigeria ALERT: Journalists, two others, arrested

Kayode Fasua, editor of the “Contact” newspaper, and Tunde Ajayi, editor of the “Class” newspaper, were on Wednesday, November 26, 2003, arrested by personnel of the Ekiti state command of the Nigeria police. Also arrested were Michael Dada and Bola Fatile, both said to be staff of the Ministry of Justice.

According to Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Nigeria, the four persons were arrested for being in possession of copies of the Ekiti Razor newspaper, which was said to contain material intended to disparage the reputation of the state governor, Ayo Fayose. The Assistant Police Commissioner in charge of the Criminal Investigations Department (CID), Emmanuel Zanu, also alleged that the publication contained “inciting information that could jeopardize the peace and order in the state”.

Mr Zanu claimed that the security forces had received intelligence that the journalists and their colleagues were conveying copies of the allegedly inciteful publication to the state for circulation. The police, accordingly, intercepted the four at a roadblock and found several copies of the newspaper in their vehicle. Zanu indicated that the journalists and others would be charged to court immediately ongoing investigations are concluded.

The MFWA is concerned about the increasing spate of harassments, arrests and detentions of journalists in Nigeria for publications and comments that the government and state authorities find critical or disparaging Only on Monday, November 24, personnel of the police CID in Lagos arrested and detained three editors of the “Insider Weekly” because of a story carried in the November 24, 2003 edition of the magazine. The publication alleged that top officials of the government of President Olusegun Obasanjo were involved in the illegal bunkering of crude oil. Osa Director, editor-in-chief, Chuks Onwudinjo and Janet Mba-Afolabi, both executive editors, were all kept in police custody until Wednesday, November 26 when, following representations by the magazine’s lawyers and pressures from the Media Rights Agenda (MRA) and other prodemocracy advocates, they were charged to court and released on bail.

The magazine has, in fact, alleged that even before these arrests, top-level security officials and politicians had been scheming, through “orthodox and unorthodox means”, to destroy the magazine for its perceived opposition to the Obasanjo administration.

MFWA appeals to the government of President Obasanjo to demonstrate a greater tolerance of, and respect for, the basic democratic tenets of media freedom and freedom of expression in Nigeria.

 

Nigeria ALERT: Reporter arrested

On November 21, 2003, the Benue State police in Makurdi arrested and detained Emmanuel Uja, a correspondent of the Sun newspaper of Nigeria, at the State Criminal Investigation Department (SCID).

According to Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) Nigeria sources, the journalist was picked up at about 10:00am during a function in Makurdi and driven away in a waiting Peugeot 504 station wagon. The police turned down appeals by Emmanuel and other reporters at the function, to allow him to conclude the function before reporting to the police station.

The police arrested Emmanuel on account of an article written by Murphy Ganagana, the Sun Abuja Bureau correspondent. The story was about a 16- year old girl who is said to have committed suicide by taking rat poison because her father allegedly stopped her from being promoted to the next class.

The police turned down pleas by other journalists at the event to allow Emmanuel to cover the function before reporting to the police, especially as he was not the author of the article. They bundled the journalist into the waiting car and took him to the SCID.

Nearly 20 members of the Correspondents Chapel of the Nigeria Union of Journalists (NUJ) subsequently staged a protest at the office of the Assistant Commissioner of Police SCID and demanded the immediate release of their colleague.

The police later released Emmanuel and instructed him to produce Murphy Ganagana, the author of the story on November 26, 2003.

Nigeria ALERT: Three editors detained for criminal defamation

Three senior editors of the “Insider Weekly” magazine were on November 24, 2003, arrested and detained by police authorities in Lagos, Nigeria. They were accused of “sedition” and “criminal defamation”, in connection with a story published in the November 24, 2003 edition of the magazine.

According to Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Nigeria, Chucks Onwudinjo and Janet Mba-Afolabi, both executive editors, and Osa Director, editor-in-chief, were picked up at about 2:00pm on Monday and held at the Panti police station in Yaba, Lagos for two days. They were charged to court on Wednesday November 26, for allegedly conspiring to publish seditious information against Vice President Abubakar Atiku and General Aliyu Muhammed Gusau (Rtd), National Security Advisor to President Olusegun Obasanjo, thereby committing criminal defamation.

Criminal defamation is punishable by imprisonment under Sections 518 (6), 51 1(c) and 375 of the Criminal Code of Nigeria. The journalists all pleaded not guilty, and were granted bail in the sum of N200,000 (about US $1,515). They are to reappear in court on January 12, 2004.

The MFWA appeals to the authorities in Nigeria to pursue the option of a rejoinder, and to discontinue the criminal defamation charges against the journalists because they have the effect of intimidating journalists and restraining them from investigating and reporting issues in the public interest.

Mali ALERT: Three radio station staff detained

Three staff of the privately-owed Radio SIDO fm station are being detained at the Ségou prison, 200 km south-west of Bamako, capital of Mali. The Ségou court charged Mamoutou Traoré, senior administrator of Radio SIDO, his deputy, Gatta Bah and Amadou Chérif Haïdara, a presenter, with the “offence” of “slander and incitement to violence.”

The three were arrested and detained following a suit filed on October 20, 2003, by Souleymane Doumbia, lawyer and bailiff, on behalf of the National Agricultural Development Bank (BNDA). Also detained was Mahamadou Kounta Dicko, Secretary General of the opposition African Solidarity for Development and Integration (SADI) party.

On November 5, the court released Dicko due to poor health; but declined an application to release Haïdara on the same grounds of ill health.

According to the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Mali, lawyer Souleymane Doumbia brought a writ against the management of Radio SIDO and the opposition leader after a talk programme during which listeners were invited to express their grievances in a phone-in session.

Between 1991 and 1993, some inhabitants of Soroba, a small village in the Konodimini district located 23 km from Ségou formed an association and contracted a loan of FCFA4,312,000 from the BNDA to finance individual projects. Some of the villagers were, however, unable to liquidate their loans within the stipulated time frame. Consequently, the bank hired Doumbia to recover the outstanding balances on the loan.

Doumbia, relying on the Ségou court verdict No.94 of April 25, 2002, seized 83 cattle belonging to the villagers. The April 25, 2002 verdict ordered the villagers to settle CFA1,786,553 owing on the loan and in addition pay  CFA150,000 as damages.

On June 18, 2002, 52 of the cattle were auctioned for CFA2,250,000 and the rest returned.

During the radio call-in session, some of the villagers complained about the indiscriminate mortgaging of their cattle, even though they claimed that they had redeemed their part of the loan.

Judgement on the substantive case is scheduled for November 18, 2003. The MFWA appeals to the authorities in Mali to effect the immediate release of the three detainees from custody until their “criminal” guilt is determined in a fair trial.

Niger UPDATE: Journalist released from detention

Ishmael Moutari, Director of the independent ANFANI FM radio station has been released from prison custody 24 hours after he was arrested and detained in Niger’s southern town of Zinder, 890 km from the capital, Niamey. Moutari was not charged with any offence.

The journalist was arrested on November 13, 2003 along with journalists Amadou Mamoudou and Harouna Mato when Abba Malam Boukar, Commissioner of the Zinder region, accused them of broadcasting information on a conflict between farmers and cattle breeders in Zinder, which then resulted in some deaths.

Amadou Mamoudou and Harouna Mato were later released but Moutari remained in detention because the police insisted that he should disclose the source of the information carried by his station.

Niger ALERT: Editor jailed

Mamane Abou, managing editor of the independent Le Républican weekly newspaper has been sentenced to six months in prison on a charge of criminal libel. The court also imposed two separate fines of CFA300,000 francs (about US$559) for cost and CFA10 million francs (US$18,622) in damages on the journalist.

Neither the journalist nor his lawyer, Souley Oumarou, was present at the closed, secret trial on November 7, 2003. The Niamey regional tribunal convicted Mamane Abou for libel, following a suit filed by Prime Minister Hama Amadou and Finance Minister Ali Badjo Gamatie.

Mamane Abou was arrested at his office in the morning of November 5, and detained at the Niamey central prison. He was charged with “conspiring with an employee to steal, and for receipt of [stolen] confidential documents.”

The arrest was in connection with an article published in the Issue No. 582 of the July 17 – 23 edition of the Le Republican newspaper. The article reported that the government had made irregular expenses to the tune of CFA4 billion francs, most of which are alleged to have gone to businessmen close to the Prime Minister. The newspaper also published a number of documents, allegedly leaked from the Public Treasury, to corroborate the claims made in the article.

The publication sparked off series of press conferences from the Prime Minister and the Minister of Finance, who threatened that the “government would take legal action” against the Le Républican managing editor. Abou is also the owner of the Nouvelle Imprimerie du Niger (NIN), the biggest printing house in the country. For many years, he was the president of the Association of Independent Media Publishers in Niger (ANEPI).

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) notes the regrettable failure of the authorities in Niger to grant Abou the opportunity to respond to the charges against him – a basic condition in any fair trial. We call on the government of President Mamadou Tandja to ensure the immediate and unconditional release of Mamane Abou from prison; and to guarantee the legitimate right of journalists in the country to receive and share information on issues of public interest.

Niger ALERT: Editor in detention

Mamane Abou, managing editor of the Le Republican newspaper was, in the morning of Wednesday November 5, 2003 arrested at his office and detained at the civilian prison in Niamey, the capital. Abou is charged with “conspiring with an employee to steal, and for receipt of [stolen] confidential documents.”

According to the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA)-Niger, Abou was served with an arrest warrant issued by the ‘investigative magistrate’ of the Niamey Regional Tribunal.

The editor’s arrest is in connection with an article, which was published in the Issue No.582 of July 17-23, 2003, of the Le Republican newspaper. The article reported that the government made irregular expenses to the tune of CFA4 billion francs, most of which are alleged to have gone to businessmen close to the Prime Minister.

The publication provoked a series of press conferences hosted by the Minister of Finance and the Prime Minister. The officials took unkindly to the article and announced that the government would take legal action.

MFWA takes note of the government’s use of the court as an instrument of repression and political vendetta. Nearly three weeks ago, on October 14, 2003, Ibrahim Sorley, managing editor of the weekly Le Enquêteur newspaper was sentenced to a 12-month “suspended jail term” by the Niamey Regional Court. Sorley was also barred from staying in the capital, Niamey for three months. He was charged with “inciting ethnic hatred and regionalism” following the publication of an article imputing nepotism in the award of government contracts.

MFWA appeals to the government of Prime Minister M. Hama Amadou to immediately and unconditionally release Mamane Abou from custody; and to discontinue the charges being brought against him merely for allegedly receiving “confidential documents.”

We request you to kindly protest the arrest and detention of Abou, and the repeated use of the courts to intimidate journalists and curtail critical media comment in Niger.