Home Blog Page 65

Nigeria: Journalist Arrested, Forced to Delete Photographs

In the morning of January 25, 2017, Ms Ujunwa Atueyi, a journalist with the privately-owned daily, ‘The Guardian, was arrested, detained for hours in a vehicle and forced to delete pictures she had taken of a raid on motorists at a Lagos bus stop by a police taskforce and city environment officers.

A seven-member team of policemen and officials of the Lagos State Task Force on Environmental and Special Offences Unit conducted an operation to clear the Cele Bus Stop, along Apapa-Oshodi Expressway.

Atueyi who was on a beat at the station, captured the chaotic scene of fleeing motorists, passengers and passers-by on her mobile phone. Atueyi also captured one young man who was being brutalized by members of the taskforce on suspicion of having given a tip-off about the operation to the motorists. The reporter was arrested while taking pictures of the scene and was forced into a waiting Black Maria vehicle for interrogation.

The Guardian newspaper reported on its website that despite identifying herself as a journalist, Atueyi was driven away, together with two other people who were arrested. She was later transferred into a Toyota Hilux van by the team leader who interrogated her in an intimidating tone.

After, the interrogation, the team leader, whose name Atueyi did not know, she compelled her to delete the photographs she had taken and then collected and checked the phone to ensure that she had actually deleted them. Thereafter, he ordered the van driver to stop at Mile Two where he told the journalist: “Madam, you can come down here, we are sorry for the stress we caused you.” The van sped off after she alighted.

The journalist was performing her legitimate duty and so her arrest and detention by the members of the Lagos City taskforce was unwarranted. The MFWA therefore calls on the Lagos City authorities to investigate the matter and bring the perpetrators to book.

Liberia: Information Minister Abuses Reporter at an Official Function

Liberia’s Information Minister has molested a female journalist during a press conference in the capital Monrovia, on January 23, 2017.

Reports say the Minister, Eugene Nagbe, flared up when Estelle Liberty Kemo from Power TV asked about a recent row between him and an opposition Member of Parliament, Moses Kollie.

Reports say in response to the reporter, Minister Nagbe repeatedly yelled at her to “go and ask her boyfriend, Representative Moses Kollie.”

The incident, which occurred during the President’s State of the Nation address in the Capitol Building in Monrovia, has drawn protests from media groups and the public in Liberia.

On January 24, the director of Power TV and veteran journalist Aaron Kollie, filed a complaint backed by a video of the incident with the Liberian Press Union which has taken up the matter.

Also, the Secretary General of the Female Journalists Association of Liberia (FeJAL), Antoinette Sendolo said in a statement: “We out-rightly denounce the irresponsible and unruly attitude of Mr. Nagbe and demand a prompt public apology to Madam Kemoh and the Female Journalists Association of Liberia because his comments have caused Madam Kemoh marital and professional embarrassment and has brought her to public ridicule.”

The Reporters Association of Liberia on their part says the attack was “unjustified and provocative.” In a press statement, the Association noted that accusing “Reporter Kemo who is a married woman, of having another man as a boyfriend without any proves, was unwarranted.”

The MFWA also finds it regrettable that a Minister of state could attempt to embarrass a journalist in public. It is offensive for the minister to allege without proof that the Power TV reporter is a girlfriend of his political rival. Mr. Nagbe’s behavior also amounts to chauvinism, and is unbecoming of a Minister of state. We therefore call on President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf to cause the matter to be investigated and to sanction the minister for a conduct that clearly reflects negatively on her government.

Nigeria: Police Raid Newspaper Office, Arrest Two Journalists

Police have raided the office the Premium Times newspaper in Nigeria and arrested two of its staff.

Dapo Olorunyomi, publisher and Evelyn Okakwu, judiciary correspondent of were arrested on January 19, 2017 by plain-clothed officers who also conducted a thorough search at the office, although they produced no search warrant or arrest warrant, according to reports.

Police spokesman, Don Awunah, told the Management of Premium Times that the arrests followed defamation complaints lodged by lawyers for the Chief of Army Staff, Tukur Buratai. The incident came days after the paper refused a written request from the Nigerian Army to retract news stories about them and their operations.

Olorunyomi and Okakwu were interrogated and detained at the Abuja Police Headquarters for hours before being released. They were asked to report to the police the following day (January 20, 2017).

According to a police source who spoke to the Management of Premium Times, the authorities could “surprise” the journalists with summons to appear before a Magistrate’s Court where they could obtain an order to detain the them. But the Management of the paper remains defiant. The Editor-in-Chief, Musikilu Mojeed, said the paper would not be intimidated.

The arrest and detention of the journalists caused outrage across Nigeria.

Some prominent personalities in the Nigerian media landscape also wrote a letter to President Muhammadu Buhari to express outrage and call for an end to attacks on the media by the security services. The letter decried what it termed an attempt to criminalise the work of the media and “a drive to frighten, cower and stop this critical constitutionally mandated work through aggressive use of state security apparatus.”

The MFWA’s national partner organisation in Nigeria, International Press Centre (IPC) have also condemned the arrest of the journalists. In a statement, the IPC said “the attack on Premium Times as well as the harassment of other journalists in recent times are completely antithetical to democratic values and norms at the core of which are the rights to free speech and media freedom.” The IPC also called on the Army authorities “to seek legal redress or make use of the instrumentality of the media regulatory agencies, should they be convinced that there had been professional misconduct on the part of Premium Times and its editors.”

The MFWA is equally concerned about the arrest of the two journalists and other journalists in recent times and calls for an end to the harassment of media professionals by the security agencies.

 

Statement of West Africa CSOs on the Gambian Crisis

0

TEXT OF THE WEST AFRICAN CIVIL SOCIETY FORUM DELIVERED BY THE ACTING GENERAL SECREATRY OF WACSOF, MR. AUWAL IBRAHIM MUSA (RAFSANJANI) AT THE PRESS CONFERENCE ON THE POLITICAL SITUATION IN THE GAMBIA, HELD AT THE REGIONAL SECRETARIAT IN ABUJA, ON 18TH JANUARY 2017.

On the 1st of December 2016, Gambians went to the polls to vote for a president for the fifth time since current leader Yahya Jammeh came to power in a 1994 coup. Over the past 22 years, President Jammeh and the Gambian security forces have used enforced disappearances, torture, intimidation, and arbitrary arrests as well as summary executions to suppress the people of the Gambia in order to preserve Jammeh’s grip on power. Ahead of the December 2016 election, the government repeated these tactics, with a crackdown on opposition parties that extinguished all hopes for a free and fair election.

The government’s crackdown began with an arrest of over 90 opposition activists, including those arrested with the prominent UDP activist Solo Sandeng, for participating in largely peaceful protests. Courts convicted 39 opposition members and sentenced them to three-year terms, including UDP leader Ousainou Darboe and many of the UDP leadership. Jammeh has also repeatedly threatened opposition parties. 

The abuses committed since April 2016, as well as Jammeh’s repeated threats, intimidation and killings of the opposition and supporters, as well as the Civil Society and journalists, and its domination of state media have reinforced a climate of fear among many opposition politicians and activists that severely limits their ability to criticize and hold Jammeh and his government to account.

International human rights law provides important protections that the Jammeh government has frequently violated, including the rights to security of person, to a fair trial, and to freedom of expression, association, and peaceful assembly. Article 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which Gambia has ratified, guarantees the right of every citizen to take part in the conduct of public affairs, the right to vote and to be elected and the right to have access to public service.

In 2001, the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) adopted the Protocol on Democracy and Good Governance (ECOWAS Protocol), which includes specific provisions promoting democratic elections. The ECOWAS Protocol provides that political parties should “have the right to carry out their activities freely, within the limits of the law” and “without hindrance or discrimination in any electoral process. The freedom of the opposition shall be guaranteed.” The Protocol also requires that all parties can meet and organize peaceful demonstrations in advance of elections while the armed forces and police shall be non-partisan and shall remain loyal to the nation.

WACSOF has been at the forefront in promoting tenure limit in the region to ensure peaceful, transparent, democratic and participatory election in West Africa. Incidentally, Yahaya Jameh has consistently refused to comply with this as well as the ECOWAS Protocol on Democracy and Good Governance.

The continuous gross violation of the fundamental human rights of the Gambians by dictator Jammeh necessitated WACSOF to intensify a peaceful campaign for election in the Gambia.

The election was conducted in the most peaceful and transparent process according to both local and international observers as well as by the Gambians themselves. After the overwhelming defeat of dictator Jammeh, he conceded defeat and congratulated the President-elect Adama Barrow. This act of Jammeh was hailed by many organizations including WACSOF, unfortunately the dictator as usual was only trying to deceive and mortgage the collective will of the people of Gambia and the electoral process as he withdrew his acceptance and annulled the results on December 2.

Efforts have been ongoing to persuade the brutal dictator to comply with his earlier concession of defeat and to respect the will of the Gambians. The effort of the ECOWAS under the leadership of its Chairperson Pres. Ellen Johnson Sirleaf of Liberia together with Pres. Muhammadu Buhari or Nigeria, Pres. John Mahama of Ghana, and Pres. Ernest Bai Koroma of Sierra Leone has not yielded results for a peaceful transfer of power.

WACSOF expresses concern over the intention of Yahya Jammeh to plunge the country into anarchy. WACSOF is therefore calling on the International Community, Private Sector, Development Partners, United Nations, African Union, European Union, and the ECOWAS to undertake effective and necessary measures to ensure that Pres. Yahya Jammeh hands over power on January 19 to the president-elect Adama Barrow:

We call on all governments to condemn the actions of Yahya Jammeh and transmit such statement to the Gambian embassy in their country. 

We also call on the Gambians to embark on a peaceful civil disobedience against the President Jammeh’s regime until it relinquishes power.

We urge all CSOs and the Media all over the world to continue to solidarize with the people of the Gambia until their verdict as expressed in the December 1 presidential election is respected and the new president inaugurated.

The Gambia: Seven Foreign Journalists Expelled

Seven journalists who had gone to The Gambia to cover the upcoming inauguration of President-elect Adama Barrow, were on January 16, 2017 prevented from entering the country.

The MFWA’s sources say upon arriving at the Banjul International Airport, security officers briefly detained the journalists at the airport and later deported them to neighbouring Senegal.

According to the sources, four of the journalists were from the regional bureau of CCTV in Kenya, one photojournalist from AFP and two journalists on assignment for  Swedish Blankspot.

The expulsion of the seven journalists brings to nine the number of foreign journalists deported from the country. On December 12, 2016, two journalists with Al Jazeera were prevented from covering post-election activities in The Gambia and were detained overnight and subsequently deported to Senegal.

The MFWA condemns the detention and subsequent deportation of the journalists. The current developments in The Gambia require a vibrant media to keep the citizens and the international community informed. The nation is facing a political crisis following President Yahya Jammeh’s refusal to accept the December 1, 2016 elections result after losing to Adama Barrow. In a bid to prevent the media from covering post-election activities and the impending inauguration of President-elect Barrow, the outgoing regime has resorted to a severe crackdown on the media, civil society activists and citizens in which there have been arrests, detentions and shutdown of radio stations in the country. The MFWA urges the Gambian government led by out-going President Yahya Jammeh to respect freedom of expression and press freedom and allow both the local and international media to do their work without any interference.

 

Nigeria: Police Arrest Publisher of Online News Portal for Alleged Defamation

Nigerian police have arrested Desmond Utomwen, publisher of FreshNews, an online journal, following a defamation complaint by a custom official. The police also seized files and equipment from his office.

The MFWA’s correspondent in Nigeria reports that at 11.34 am on January 13, 2017, police officers led by Anthony Enobakhare and Abubakar Iweafeno, showed a warrant of arrest and proceeded to search the publisher’s office before arresting him.

The officers confiscated Utomwen’s laptop, mobile phone, file and other official documents before taking him away to the Force Criminal Investigation and Intelligence Department, FCIID in Area 10, Garki, Abuja, for questioning.

Utomwen, who was denied access to his lawyer, was eventually released on bail later that day following the intervention of Nigerian Union of Journalists (NUJ) and the Centre against Brutality and for the Safety of Journalists in Africa (CABSOJA).

The arrest followed a petition by the legal counsel to Umar Faruk, a senior officer of the Nigerian Customs Service who alleged that publisher had defamed him. The defamation case goes back to August 2016 when FreshNews contacted Faruk for his reaction to some information it had obtained about him which could ruin his reputation. Observing the ethics of journalism, FreshNEWS decided not to publish the story until it has received Faruk’s response.

Our correspondent says the operation was apparently aimed at destroying or seizing all documents related to the allegations about Faruk.

It is clearly unacceptable for a publisher to be arrested and for his media house to be ransacked simply for possessing and not necessarily publishing information about a public figure. The MFWA calls on the Nigerian police to ensure that all the equipment and documents seized from Utomwen are returned to him.

 

Niger: Shirking Accountability – Municipal Authorities Ban Protest March against Maladministration

The municipal authorities in Niamey have prohibited a demonstration planned by civil society in Niger to demand better public service delivery.

According to the MFWA correspondent, a coalition of civil society organisations in the Nigerien capital scheduled a march on January 13, 2017. The protest march was to be climaxed with a rally to denounce inefficient governance of the city. However, the mayor, Assane Seydou formally notified the organisers on January 12 that the protest is prohibited.

Following the prohibition order, the organisers appealed the decision at the Niamey Tribunal. But to their disappointment, the court ruled in favour of the city authorities, citing “security reasons.”

Meanwhile, Article 23 of Niger’s constitution says “the State recognizes and guarantees the freedom of movement, the freedoms of association, assembly, procession and manifestation within the conditions defined by the law.

“Of course one of the conditions defined by law is manifest threat to public peace or national security. In the present instance, the defendants did not adduce any compelling evidence of real or even remote threat to public peace,” our correspondent reported.

The MFWA appeals to the authorities in Niamey to respect citizens’ right to publicly express their views about the administration of their city, including through demonstrations. As representatives and servants of the people, the municipal authorities should not shy away from demands for accountability and efficient public service delivery.

Nigeria: Journalists Barred from Abuja High Court

Journalists who went to the Federal High Court in Abuja to cover a case in which Nnamdi Kanu, leader of the pro-separatist group, Indigenous People of Biafra, (IPOB) is being tried for treason, found themselves initially barred from entering the courtroom.

Security officers told reporters who had been assigned to cover the hearing on January 10, 2017, that the presiding judge, Justice Binta Nyako, has ordered that journalists be barred from the courtroom. They claimed the judge had decided that prosecution witnesses would be shielded, hence the ban on reporters, except those with Federal High Court tags.

According to reports, confusion broke out when security officers attempted to enforce the ban. The journalists protested that they were not given prior notice. Others complained that their application for badges have not been processed after three years.

The protests reportedly created some confusion, forcing the court authorities to back down. However, the reporters were in for another unpleasant surprise, as they were forced to follow proceedings from behind a screen.

The MFWA calls on the judicial authorities in Nigeria to communicate to the media and in a timely manner procedures and conditions for covering cases to avoid squabbles between the media and the authorities at the courts. We also call on the authorities to fast-track the issuance of badges to journalists who have applied for them to enable them access the courts for coverage of cases.

The Gambia: Licenses of Four Radio Stations Revoked

The Ministry of Information and Communication Infrastructure of The Gambia has revoked the licenses of Hilltop Radio, Afri Radio, Taranga FM and Paradise FM.

 In a letter addressed to the four radio stations, Saul Njie who signed the letter on behalf of the Permanent Secretary of the Ministry, said, “I am directed to inform you that your license to operate has been revoked with immediate effect. Thank you for your cooperation.” There was no reason assigned for the revocation of the license of the radio stations neither was there a clear indication as to who had directed him to revoke the licenses of the target stations.

The revocation of the licenses of the four radio stations implies that the stations have been forced to close down until their licenses are reinstated. 

The revocation of the licenses of the radio stations comes days after they were ordered to cease broadcasting. Hilltop Radio, Afri Radio, and Taranga FM were ordered by the National Intelligence Agency (NIA) to stop broadcasting on January 1, 2017. Afri Radio was however allowed on air on January 3, 2017 on condition that the station will play only music.

In the case of Paradise FM it was ordered by persons claiming to be from the Ministry of Communication to cease broadcasting on January 8.

While there have been no official communication on the reasons for the order to cease broadcasting and subsequent revocation of the licenses of the radio stations on January 9, many believe it is as a result of the radio stations’ coverage of activities of President-Elect Adama Barrow and his impending inauguration scheduled for January 19, 2017.

 The MFWA condemns the revocation of the licenses of the media organisations. In the wake of a political crisis in The Gambia after President Yahya Jammeh refused to accept the outcome of the December 1, 2016 elections in which he lost to Adama Barrow, vibrant media have become extra necessary to keep the public informed about happenings in the country. We therefore urge the authorities in The Gambia to ensure that freedom of expression, press freedom and access to information are respected in the country.

 

Media Foundation – Holiday Office Closure Notice

0

Dear Colleagues,

The Media Foundation office has closed for the holidays from now till Friday, 6 January . We will be back on Monday, 09 January 2017.
We wish you a Merry Christmas and a Prosperous Happy New Year.

MFWA Team

——————————————

Chers Collègues,

Le bureau de la Media Foundation est fermé pour les vacances à partir du vendredi 6 janvier.  Nous serons de retour au bureau le lundi, 09 janvier 2017.

Nous vous souhaitons un Joyeux Noël et une Bonne Fête !

Équipe MFWA

——————————————

Media Foundation for West Africa

30 Duade Street, Kokomlemle

P.O. Box LG 730, Legon

Accra, Ghana

Tel : +233-302-242470

Tel/Fax : +233-302-221084

Email : [email protected]

Website: www.mfwa.org

 

12 years On: No Justice for Murdered Gambian Journalist Deyda Hydara

Twelve years ago today, prominent Gambian Journalist Deyda Hydra was murdered on his way from work.

Hydara who was the editor of The Point newspaper was gunned down in a drive-by shooting by unknown assailants on December 16, 2004 on his way from work. Hydara was also the president of the Gambia Press Union (GPU) and a well-known critic of Gambian President Yahya Jammeh and led advocacy efforts against legislative restrictions on press freedom in The Gambia.

The State’s Response to the Murder 
After Hydara’s murder, the state opened an investigation which was closed in less than a month. No arrests were made and no one was held responsible for the murder. Not only did the state not properly investigate the murder but it also made it a point to restrict and intimidate those who called for proper investigations.

On December 30, 2014, Sam Obi, a Nigerian journalist was arrested and subjected to thorough questioning by officials of the Serious Crime Unit of Gambia Police Force for six hours. Obi’s arrest followed an interview he granted to Radio France International (RFI) about a march organised by the Gambia Press Union (GPU) to protest the murder of Hydara.

On October 13, 2005, the Gambian authorities ordered the management of The Point to discontinue the “Good Morning Mr. President” column started by Deyda Hydara. The then director general of the National Intelligence Agency (NIA), Daba Marrena, told Pap Saine, the then managing editor of The Point that President Jammeh and other government officials were not happy with the column. Following the directive, the column was taken out from the subsequent editions of the newspaper. The management of the newspaper said the authorities threatened to close down the newspaper if it failed to remove the column.

Further, on the first anniversary (December 16, 2005) of Hydara’s murder, officers from the Gambia Police Intervention Force sealed off the site of Hydara’s murder preventing members of the Gambia Press Union (GPU) and foreign journalists from accessing the site. The officers claimed the GPU did not have authority to assemble what they described as a “large crowd.” This resulted in a clash. Ramatoulie Charreh, a female photojournalist who attempted to take pictures of the clash had her camera seized. The officers also grabbed her and folded her hands behind her back. She immediately became unconscious and was rushed to the hospital where she regained consciousness and was later discharged.

Ten months after that, the NIA on October 27, 2006, arrested and questioned Musa Saidykhan, then editor of The Independentnewspaper  following an interview he granted to other newspapers on Hydara. Some newspapers, quoted Saidykhan who had then returned from The All Africa Editors Forum in South Africa as saying that then South African President Thabo Mbeki said he would assist the Gambian authorities to resolve Hydara’s murder. The NIA took Saidykhan to their office, interrogated him for many hours after which he was made to write a statement on his trip to South Africa as well as answer questions relating to his profession.

The government silenced media who spoke about Hydara’s murder and also attempted to vilify the slain journalist. In an interview on the state-owned Gambian Radio and Television Stations (GRTS) on June 9, 2009, President Yahya Jammeh quoted the findings of NIA which concluded that Hydara’s gruesome murder was as a “result of personal revenge by a jealous husband, whose wife committed adultery with Hydara.”

Application at ECOWAS Court

On November 23, 2011 Hydara’s family together with the International Federation of Journalists-Africa filed a suit at the ECOWAS Court against The Gambia. In their application, Hydara’s family argued that The Gambia;

  • failed to effectively investigate the murder of journalist Deyda Hydara;
  • caused and tolerated impunity concerning the death of Hydara;
  • violated the right to freedom of expression;
  • failed to provide redress to Hydara’s family, because failing to properly investigate the crime inhibited the family from obtaining compensation.

At the trial, Captain Lamin K. Saine a senior official NIA who was the head of the team that conducted investigations into Hydara’s murder testified as their witness. He defended the NIA investigations and said it was prompt, independent, and that the NIA had included the family. Saine also admitted that the NIA dedicated only 22 days to investigating Hydara’s murder.

On June 10, 2014, the Court found the Gambian government guilty of failing to properly investigate Hydara’s murder. The Court noted that the NIA investigations did not carry out any ballistic, bullets and or weapon tests as part of the investigation. It said by failing to conduct proper investigations, government allowed impunity to thrive in the country. The Court consequently ordered the Gambian government to pay $50,000 in damages Hydara’s family and $10,000 as legal costs.

Two Years After Court Ruling

 The Gambia is yet to comply with the ruling of the Court just as it has failed to comply with the two earlier rulings of the Court – the cases of Chief Ebrimah Maneh and Musa Saidykhan. Meanwhile the freedom of expression condition in the country has worsened.

The MFWA again appeals to the ECOWAS to ensure that The Gambia complies with the rulings of the Court and ensure justice for Hydara and his family.

The Gambia: Two Al-Jazeera journalists Deported

On December 11, 2016, two journalists working for the Arabic-language service of international news organisation Al-Jazeera were held by security forces in The Gambia. 

Al Jazeera’s Mauritania bureau chief Zeinebou Mint Erebih and cameraman Mohamed Ould Beidar reported that they were taken away from their hotel by plainclothes officers and detained in the night of December 11, 2016.

Erebih and Beidar were released on December 12 and transported to Banjul airport where they were deported to neighbouring Senegal. While reasons for the arrest, detention and subsequent of the journalists were not made to them, news reports attribute it to an interview they conducted with President-elect Adama Barrow.