Home Blog Page 4

WPFD 2024: Gov’ts must ensure an open civic space for environmental journalists, activists in West Africa

The celebration of World Press Freedom Day (WPFD) 2024 is under the theme “A Press for the Planet: Journalism in the Face of the Environmental Crisis”. The global event to mark the day, to be held in Santiago, Chile, as well as the national celebrations, will focus on two critical issues – the global environmental crisis and the shrinking space for media practice.

The theme could not have been more appropriate, as the world is living through a perilous environmental upheaval. Weather patterns are erratic, sea levels are rising at an alarming rate, threatening coastal communities with erosion and displacement. Biodiversity loss, mainly from indiscriminate logging and unsustainable agricultural practices, coupled with environmental degradation from pollution, sand winning, mining and hydrocarbon production have pushed the global ecosystem to the brink of a meltdown.

In West Africa, the effects of the crisis have included drought, food insecurity, and pastoral livestock movements that have destroyed livelihoods and fueled conflicts, tensions and instability in many countries in the region.

The alarming effects of the climate change crisis in the region have been exacerbated by a growing restriction of the civic space that impedes the work of journalists and activists working to help save the environment.

These environmental journalists and activists are often targeted by individuals and corporations who amass wealth through activities that degrade the environment. The intimidation comes in the form of death threats, physical attacks, arrests and detention and other forms of judicial harassment, and hate and disinformation campaigns aimed at isolating the targeted activists. Sometimes, those who feed off the destruction of the environment influence even traditional and administrative authorities in the communities to antagonise those working to prevent environmental abuses.

For instance, in January 2021, Ghanaian journalist Erastus Asare Donkor and two others from Joy News who were reporting on illegal mining in forest reserves were arrested and detained by military officers. Erastus’ persistent reports have exposed how illegal mining activities by the powerful and politically exposed persons in Ghana are destroying water bodies and many sources of drinking water in the country.

“We were detained unlawfully for five hours in one of our visits to the Apaprama forest. It took several interventions to get us released,” Erastus Asare narrated his ordeal to participants at the Media Foundation for West Africa’s WPFD’s webinar held on May 2, 2024. “My driver was assaulted, punched in the face. Our vehicle’s windscreen was destroyed. Our camera’s were destroyed. They wiped everything clear. If we had not hidden a memory card, we wouldn’t have done that expose on what was happening in the forest.”

In some countries, some governments proscribe organisations working to protect the environment, labelling them as terrorists or unpatriotic foreign agents. Media organisations involved in environmental activism are targeted with closures and other forms of harassment, while the public is dissuaded with heavy-handed police response when they decide to go on demonstrations. It is often a desperate fight against a toxic mix of rapacious capitalism and colluding, repressive authorities at various levels of the governance hierarchy, who use extraction, plunder, violence, death and domination to perpetuate their inhumane acts.

As a freedom of expression organisation, the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) has been working over the years to highlight these challenges. Besides the reporting and campaigns to end impunity over attacks on environmental journalists and activists, MFWA has produced a number of publications highlighting the issues and their impact on development.

For example, the MFWA highlighted the continued gender imbalance in climate decision spaces via this blog which was published to commemorate International Women’s Day 2022.  The write-up bemoaned the lack of progress towards gender balance in climate negotiations as agreed during the Eighteenth Conference of the Parties (COP18) and as envisaged in decision 36/CP.7 under the Convention and its Kyoto Protocol.

The MFWA has also demonstrated its commitment to environmental issues through the publication of over a dozen stories about the environment and climate change by its investigative journalism project, The Fourth Estate. The online newsroom has highlighted the debilitating effect of air pollution on children’s health, raised alarm over the eroding shorelines of Keta, in the Volta Region of Ghana and decried the environmental devastation wreaked on certain communities in Ghana by illegal mining activities. The Fourth Estate also published a story on the clearing of a 100-acre protected forest by a beer-producing investor and an investigative piece on the illegal cutting of rosewood in northern Ghana for export to China.

Recognizing the urgent need to improve the capacity of journalists to respond to the climate challenge, the MFWA in October 2022 started a five-month Fellowship Programme on Climate Change for journalists selected from 10 West African Countries.  The Fellowship, which involved three months’ residential training in Accra, included intensive practical training workshops on climate change, its challenges and impact and how to report them.

We believe that a relentless media focus from an informed and human-interest standpoint is crucial to stimulating awareness and action regarding the environmental challenge confronting the world. It is therefore crucial for urgent measures to be taken to improve the civic space to enable journalists, activists and ordinary citizens to participate in public discourse on the critical environmental issues confronting the world today.

In this regard, we urge governments in West Africa to take steps to uphold in practice the many national laws and international instruments guaranteeing the independence of the media, the right to freedom of expression and access to information. They should do this by condemning attacks on journalists and activists as well as by ensuring effective investigation and prosecution of such attacks.

MFWA marks WPFD 2024 with multiple events and engagements

Globally, Africa is the least contributor to the rise in greenhouse emissions, with a carbon footprint estimated at just 4% of the world pollution metric. However, communities across the continent are disproportionately impacted by a continuously worsening climate crisis. The sub-Saharan region, especially West Africa, is known to be one of the worst impacted by the climate crisis.

Amidst the worsening threat to human life, wildlife and ecology, journalists are playing a pivotal role – sometimes as activists – in calling attention to the existential threats and the attendant human suffering. As they spotlight the environmental issues and also expose perpetrators who hurt the earth to enrich themselves, they often face threats, opposition and danger.

Given the foregoing, the focus of the 2024 commemoration of World Press Freedom Day is apt and timely. The global theme for the commemoration: A Press for the Planet: Journalism in the face of the Environmental Crisis, provides the appropriate opportunity to highlight the critical role of journalism in responding to the climate crises and the challenges that come with it.

Ahead of the official commemorative date of May 3, the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) is on May 2, organising a regional high-level webinar that will bring together media stakeholders, experts and journalists from the 16 countries in West Africa to deliberate on the theme: Journalism and the Growing Environmental Crises in West Africa.

The webinar will bring together journalists, climate activists and environmentalists, state actors, civil society organisations, academics and the general public to deliberate on the challenges confronting environmental journalism and ways to mitigate them. It will specifically highlight challenges that climate journalists face, including censorship, threats and attacks that they receive from individuals and corporations involved in degrading environmental practices such as unsustainable mining practices, toxic aquaculture, to mention a few. Participants are expected to proffer actionable solutions on how to collaborate and promote safer and healthier environmental practices.

At the national level, the MFWA is partnering with the government of Guinea Bissau, to host a major national public forum to mark World Press Freedom Day in the country’s capital, Bissau, on May 3. The event will bring together government officials, representatives from UNESCO, media stakeholders and journalists to deliberate on the situation of press freedom in the country.

The event in Guinea Bissau, forms part of an ongoing EU-funded three-year media freedom and freedom of expression project in the country, being implemented by the MFWA.

The WPFD event will be used to formally launch a National Comprehensive Framework on Safety of Journalists in Guinea Bissau, which has been developed with stakeholders under the EU-funded project.

“It is great to have the opportunity to bring together both state and non-state actors to deliberate on the state of media freedom and freedom of expression in Guinea Bissau and to launch a comprehensive framework that will help promote the safety of journalists in the country,” said Abigail Larbi, Director of the media and good governance programme at the MFWA, who will be joining in-country MFWA staff to mark the day.

In Ghana, the Executive Director, Sulemana Braimah, and other staff will be joining the Ghana Journalists Association (GJA) in the Eastern regional capital of Koforidua, for a national event to mark the day. The GJA event, which will be under the theme: Leveraging Journalism for a Sustainable Environment and Future will bring together government officials, traditional leaders, environmental experts and journalists.

Still in Ghana, Senior Programme Officer and Team Lead of Fact-check Ghana, MFWA’s fact-checking project, Kwaku Krobea Asante, will be facilitating a training programme for journalists on countering misinformation and disinformation in Koforidua. The programme is being organised by the Embassy of the United States in Ghana in collaboration with the Eastern regional chapter of the GJA.

 Ahead of the official commemorative day, the Executive Director of MFWA will be speaking on May 2 at an event being organised by the German Embassy in Ghana on the state of press freedom and freedom of expression in Ghana.

Across West Africa, national partner organisations of the MFWA will be engaged in different activities to mark the day.

Senegal state agencies comply with policy on public data management after MFWA Fellow’s report

Since November 2023, state agencies in Senegal have been transferring data in their possession to a national storage centre purposely built for the safekeeping of public data. The rehousing is in keeping with a policy to organize citizens’ data into a safe, reliable and readily accessible pool for national development planning.

This policy came into force in 2021 when the government built a data centre at Diamniado, a town 32 kilometres from the national capital, Dakar. However, state agencies had not been complying with transferring data to the centre until a journalist put their noncompliance into focus with an award-winning story.

That journalist is Fana Cisse, a reporter with Senegal-based PressAfrik. Her story, which jolted the state agencies into compliance is; Souveraineté numérique du Sénégal: le vrai, le faux, le flou du Datacenter de Diamniadio (Enquête).”  It loosely translates as “Senegal’s Digital Sovereignty: The True, the False, the Blur of the Diamniadio Datacenter (Survey).” It was one of six stories that Fana had filed as part of a three-month Fellowship on Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI), hosted by the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA), with funding from Co-Develop.

Award-winning story

Fana receiving her award from Alfred Nkuru, Director, Article 19, Senegal

It shone light on the fact that though Senegal had put up the Diamniado data centre to enhance the integrity of the country’s data rather than leave it in the possession of foreign entities, state agencies who were required to transfer data in their possession to that centre were not complying.

This non-compliance did not only make the Damniado data centre a white elephant but also put the data at risk of being leaked or stolen because the state institutions keeping them did not have data storage facilities that were secure enough.

 

The story has since pressured state agencies to comply with the law, with the Ministry of Health said to have transferred upwards of 80% of data in its possession to the centre as at January 2024. Another institution that has been noticeably compliant is the national rail transport company, SENTER.

On December 16, 2023, the story won an award at the sixth edition of the E-jicom Journalism Awards, specifically, the ‘Digital, Freedom of Expression and Civic Space category, sponsored by civil society organization, Article 19.

Life changing story

The story has since also led to Fana being invited by the Senegalese authorities to take part in a debate on digital sovereignty.

She has also gotten the opportunity to work with civil society organization, Jonction, which focuses on digital life, to design and propose digital solutions as part of Forum on Information and Democracy African tour on AI. Fana is also frequently invited to workshops organized by civil society organisations to advocate for digital issues.

Recently, she was selected as one of the monitors who contributed to the production of the ONNI report (Observatoire ouvert des Interférences sur les reseaux), a global community measuring Internet Censorship with focus on social media blackouts and network disruptions in times of political upheavals.

Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) Fellowship

Fana’s commendable feat is a result of her participation in the MFWA’s maiden Fellowship on DPI. Hosted in Accra, Ghana, from September 2023 to December 2023 (with post Fellowship activities ending in March 2024), the Fellowship was purposed to inculcate a culture of critical and in-depth journalism on the adoption of DPI as means of public service delivery by African governments. Focus on DPIs has become necessary because as governments adopt and deploy them for public service delivery, there have been concerns that the most marginalized in society stand serious risk of not benefitting from the DPI.

Even though the MFWA already has a tradition of hosting Fellowships for journalists under its Next Generation Investigative Journalism (NGIJ) Fellowship programme, the Fellowship on DPI was the first of its kind.

A DPI Fellowship class in session

MFWA published a call for applications for journalists from ten West African countries to apply for the opportunity to learn in-depth reporting skills on DPI.  Three hundred applications were received, with Fana being one of the applicants who went through the process and emerged as one of the 20 applicants who made the final selection for the Fellowship.

Subsequently, the Fellows received intensive training and mentoring in DPI reporting. For project deliverables, each Fellow was required to write six in-depth articles on DPI in their respective countries after the Fellowship. The award-winning story on the Diaminiado data centre was one of the six that Fana filed.

Other stories on DPI by Fana

Fana Cisse at WAMECA 2023 in Accra

The journalist has also filed other compelling stories, including, “Sénégal: l’apport décisif des nouvelles technologies de séquençage dans la gestion de la santé publique;”- which looks at how sequencing technologies has made it possible to respond to public health crises from better position of knowledge; “Sénégal: de la nécessité d’une infrastructure publique numérique à une inclusion financière sécurisée;” – which recounts how the adoption of digital financial systems and platforms have been innovative and have not truly been beneficial to the people,  andDonnées ouvertes au Sénégal : produire de la valeur en termes de bonne gouvernance et renforcer la confiance publique;” which advocates the use of open data in Senegal to promote transparency.

Press freedom in Nigeria: The spiral of repression continues in 2024

Journalists and critical voices in Nigeria continue to face challenges in carrying out their duties and, or, expressing their opinions. From attacks on journalists to threats against media practitioners, these incidents highlight the necessity to discourage press freedom and freedom of expression violations by holding the perpetrators accountable.

Physical Attacks

On March 4, 2024, the police arrested activist Abdulganiu Olushipo after he had shared information on a WhatsApp platform detailing the alleged budgetary allocations received by Lagos Mainland Local Government. The activist’s demand for transparency and good governance from the local government chairperson, Omolola Essien, via the WhatsApp platform reportedly angered the chairperson, leading to accusations of cyberstalking and cyberbullying, ultimately resulting in his arrest.

His arrest sparked immediate protests by local youths and other groups, who accused the local government chairperson of orchestrating his arrest in response to his posts. Following public pressure, Olushipo was released on March 5, 2024, from the Surulere police station cell.

On February 23, 2024, a court Registrar and some policemen at the Federal High Court in Ilorin, the Kwara State capital, barred journalists from covering the arraignment of a former governor of the State, Dr. Abdulfattah Ahmed, allegedly on ‘orders from above.’ Efforts by Dele Oyewale, spokesman of Ilorin Zonal Command of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), eventually persuaded authorities to permit journalists entry into the court premises. However, even after gaining access, journalists were prohibited from covering the proceedings, raising concerns about transparency and access to information.

On February 23, 2024, soldiers from the Nigerian Army brutalised and arrested Dele Fasan, the South-South Bureau Chief of Galaxy Television. Fasan was recording a video footage of a labour protest over economic hardship in Uvwie, a suburb of the city of Warri, when one of the soldiers asked him to hand over his phone. Despite presenting his press ID, he was arrested and detained for an hour. The soldiers deleted the images he had recording.

Eyewitnesses reported that the soldiers physically assaulted the journalist, hitting him with their gun before handcuffing him. Fasan was released and his handcuffs removed after the intervention of the police boss and his colleagues, who appealed to the Army Commander, Major A.E Ohegbe.

On February 17, 2024, journalists covering the All Progressives Congress (APC) governorship primary election in Edo State were attacked by suspected political thugs. Despite the presence of the State Commissioner of Police, Funsho Adeboye, and some party officials at the centre, the attackers continued their rampage unchecked.

Among the victims assaulted were Fortune Oyem, a reporter with the state-owned Federal Radio Corporation of Nigeria, Bernard Akede from News Central TV, Abraham Godwin, a journalist with Arise TV, as well as cameramen from the state-owned Nigerian Television Authority (NTA) and the Federal Radio Corporation of Nigeria (FRCN). As they fled from the assailants, most of the victims lost or had their equipment seized or damaged.

Similarly, on February 9, 2024, the defendants accused of killing the Village Head of Lambata in Niger State, Alhaji Muhammad Abdulsafur, assaulted and threatened journalists covering the proceedings. The suspects pounced on cameramen from Nigerian Television Authority (NTA), Niger State Television (NSTV) and some journalists that were recording the event at the premises. They warned reporters of severe consequences if they continued reporting on the trial, emphasising that they were prepared to take action against any journalist who disregarded their warning. It took the intervention of the Court Registrar and legal counsel to diffuse the situation and ensure the safety of the journalists.

Death Threats

Threats against journalists are also a major concern. For instance, Ebule Anthony Metsese Editor-In-Chief of Fresh Angle International, an online newspaper, has raised concerns about repeated threats to his life stemming from contentious events in Warri, Delta State. Metsese highlighted the most recent threat, linked to an incident in Okere community on March 2, 2024.

The journalist stated that despite his decision not to publish the event in his community, he received warnings that he would face severe consequences if he reported on the incident. These threats, he claimed, were linked to the support his newspaper, Fresh Angle International, receives from certain individuals. Metsese noted that some of these individuals occasionally patronise his newspaper through proxies while making derogatory remarks about its professional integrity in private and social settings.

Similarly, Sufuyan Ojeifo, publisher of The Conclave, an online newspaper, has accused Mr. Ehiozuwa Johnson Agbonayinma, a Federal Commissioner with the Code of Conduct Bureau (CCB), of issuing threats to his life following Ojeifo’s report on leadership transitions within the Bureau. This accusation was made through a petition to the Area Court 1, Kubwa, Abuja, filed on December 29, 2023. In the petition, Ojeifo sought the court’s intervention to have the Force Criminal Investigation Department (FCID) FCT Police Command, Garki, Abuja, investigate his complaint of threat to life against Agbonayinma.

The court, in response to Ojeifo’s petition, directed the police to conduct a thorough investigation in accordance with Section 89(50) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA) 2015. This directive was conveyed through a referral for investigation endorsed by the court registrar on December 29, 2023. The Police Force CID acknowledged receipt of the court’s referral on January 12, 2024.

The numerous incidents of violence, intimidation, and harassment against journalists and critical voices in Nigeria are deeply concerning. The assaults, such as the brutal attack on Abdulganiu Olushipo and the harassment of Dele Fasan and Bunmi Adigun, are clear violations of press freedom and must not be tolerated.

These violations, and others recorded in Nigeria in the first quarter of 2024, are concerning, as they underline a trend of repression in the country. Nigeria recorded 12 out of a total of 39 violations reported in West Africa in the last quarter of 2023, according to the monitoring report produced by the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA).

It is imperative that journalists are able to carry out their duties, and indeed, all Nigerians are able to express their opinions including dissenting or unpopular views on issues of national interest, without fear of violence, intimidation or censorship.

In this regard, we urge the government, as a first step, to comply with the landmark judgment delivered by a Federal High Court in Abuja on February 16, 2024, directing the Federal Government to investigate attacks against journalists and prosecute perpetrators.

Stakeholders urged to collaborate against mis/disinformation ahead of Ghana’s elections 2024

A one-day forum on mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives in Ghana closed with a call on stakeholders to collaborate towards ensuring that the phenomena do not dominate the political campaigns before, during and after Ghana’s general elections in December 2024.

The media, civil society, government and media associations were urged to unite efforts towards ensuring that the elections are policed with fact-checking to ensure that they are issues-based.

The call is a summary of a number of recommendations that were made at the end of the one-day public forum which was held under the theme: Countering Mis/Disinformation and Propaganda Narratives in the 2024 Elections in Ghana.

The programme came off on Wednesday, March 27, 2024, at the Accra International Conference Center (AICC) and was organized as part of an eight-month project on mis/disinformation that the MFWA has been running since 2023, with funding from the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) of the government of the United Kingdom.

Under it, 100 media practitioners, including 75 journalists and 25 social media influencers have been trained in fact-checking to enable them to detect, expose and counter mis/disinformation.

The forum brought together 150 stakeholders from government, media, national security, the diplomatic community, traditional and religious authorities, civil society and academia. It was chaired by Rev. Dr. Ernest Adu Gyamfi, Board Chairman of Ghana’s Peace Council, with Hon. Fatimatu Abubakar, Minister for Information Designate, as the Guest of Honor.

The forum provided a platform for an incisive dialogue that consisted of compelling presentations, a panel discussion and a brainstorming session to flesh out ideas to inform strategies.

Ghana faces serious challenges with election 2024

MFWA’s Executive Director, Sulemana Braimah, delivering the welcome address

 In a welcome address, the Executive Director of the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA), Sulemana Braimah, said it was imperative for participating stakeholders to critically dialogue and brainstorm for actionable solutions because, in the upcoming election in 2024, Ghana faces challenging times.

A cross-section of the participants at the forum

According to him, while the proliferation of mis/disinformation has become a global problem, the situation is getting increasingly alarming in Africa.  He cited a recent publication by the Africa Centre for Strategic Studies which revealed that in 2023 alone, there were 189 documented disinformation campaigns in Africa.

The figure is said to be almost four times the recorded incidents in 2022. “I should add that these are documented cases. There certainly would have been several undocumented operations.

“What makes the situation more alarming for us in Ghana is that, West Africa has become the epicenter of disinformation campaigns,” Sulemana Braimah said.

According to the report by Africa Centre for Strategic Studies, in 2023, while there were 15 documented campaigns targeting North Africa; 33 in East Africa; 21 in Southern Africa; and 21 in Central Africa; there were as many as 72 campaigns that targeted 13 West African countries. The number for West Africa represents almost 40% of all the campaigns that targeted Africa.

Ghana under a scourge of mis/disinformation already

Rev. Ernest Adu Gyamfi, Board Chairman of the National Peace Council

In an acceptance speech, the Chairman of the forum, Rev. Dr. Ernest Adu Gyamfi, underscored the timeliness of the forum saying it was important that the discussions are productive because Ghana is already facing a scourge of mis/disinformation.

“As Ghana gears up for its 2024 election, the need to tackle the spread of false information and manipulative narratives has never been more pressing.”

The impact of hate speech, he said, extends beyond the election period. It perpetuates a culture of division and animosity, making it increasingly difficult for different political factions to find common ground. This polarization hampers meaningful dialogue and obstructs the search for shared solutions to complex issues.

“When inflammatory rhetoric becomes commonplace, it desensitizes individuals to the impact of their words. Respectful and civil discourse is replaced with insults and personal attacks, degrading the quality of political discussions.”

Mis/disinformation should be fought collaboratively

Ghana’s Minister Designate for Information delivering her address

On her part, the Hon. Minister Designate for Information, Fatimatu Abubakar, said the canker of mis/disinformation, as alarming as it is, should not evoke despair but provide stimulus for stakeholders to come together and fight it.

“As citizens and custodians of democracy, it is incumbent upon us to confront this challenge head-on. The integrity of our elections is not merely a matter of political expediency; it is a fundamental pillar upon which our democratic institutions rest. It is the bedrock upon which the voice of the people is heard and the will of the electorate expressed.”

She expressed lament that even though Ghana has multiple outlets in its media space, and under normal circumstances should have its citizens better informed, the space is replete with mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives.

Meanwhile, she said the government has, on its own, already been tackling the problem by means of a number of strategies, especially media literacy programmes.

Preparation is everything

Mr. Richard Sandall, Development Director at the British High Commission in Ghana, represented the British government, emphasised the absolute need for stakeholders to prepare for an onslaught of mis/disinformation in the country’s upcoming elections.

Richard Sandall, Development Director at the British High Commission in Ghana

He applauded Ghana’s democratic growth, pointing out that the successful organization of eight elections in the Fourth Republic is something to be proud of, however, there are pressures that continue to mount on the country’s democracy.

“That’s why the UK is so happy to partner with the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) and others here present on this project to implement interventions that will help counter those threats, especially given recent events in West Africa with regard to misinformation it’s really crucial that we make collective efforts to increase public awareness to help counter misinformation on Ghana’s 2024 elections. That will ultimately feed into the efforts being made to preserve and stability that Ghana enjoys within the region and help make peace and stability spread around that region.”

He said Ghana is not alone, as the UK and other countries are facing similar threats.

He urged all the beneficiaries of the training programmes organized with supported by the FCDO to put the new knowledge and skills learnt to use in countering the mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives during the elections.

Lessons from Ghana’s 2020 elections

The main work at the forum took place in a panel discussion on the guiding theme. The agenda was set by Kwaku Krobea Asante, Team Lead at Fact-Check Ghana, with a presentation on the lessons learnt from Ghana’s previous elections in 2020.

The data available from monitoring of 60 radio stations selected across the country from June 2021, with 17,280 programmes, showed that 582 indecent expressions were recorded.

The indecent statements were made by 175 individuals, most of whom were politicians. And these perpetrators were both from foreign and domestic sources.

One reason the politicians led in the perpetrations was that many of the radio stations were owned by politicians. Going into the 2024 elections, these politicians will use these politically affiliated media avenues to perpetrate mis/disinformation and their various derivatives, including hate speech, again.

The panel which undertook the discussions was comprised of Mr. Krobea-Asante, Ernest Lartey, Head of Peace and Security Programme at the Kofi Annan International Peace Training Center (KAIPTC) and Ms Gloria Hiadzi, Executive Secretary of Ghana Independent Broadcasters Association (GIBA).

Recommendations

The call on the stakeholders to unite efforts against mis/disinformation was just one of several recommendations made at the forum. The following are other recommendations that were made.

  1. Editors, show hosts and producers must institute a zero-tolerance policy for indecent language and clamp down or stand against its usage on their platforms
  2. Selection of panelists or guests for shows must be guided by issues and not necessarily balance of political opponents
  3. Media organizations are encouraged to set up dedicated fact-checking desks and mainstream fact-checking as part of the culture of news
  4. Politicians who own media organizations should make way and allow professionals to manage their media outlets for them.
  5. Civil society organisations, media houses and fact-checkers are encouraged to collaborate against mis/disinformation through organising media and information literacy programmes, fact-checking capacity-building workshops for journalists and forums on information disorder and elections.
  6. Politicians should make conscious efforts to use the services of trained researchers so they can communicate factual, well-researched issues.
  7. Government and the leadership of political parties are advised to institute for their communication department and officers policies of sticking to relevant issues, facts and shunning disinformation and abusive language.
  8. Civil society organizations are encouraged to keep on activism for the passage of the Broadcasting Bill
  9. Media owners should regularly organize media literacy education for staff in order to improve the skills of staff
  10. Media associations should also enforce high journalism standards on members
  11. Regulatory bodies are encouraged to continuously monitor and invite media owners, hosts and journalists to dialogue and build consensus on upholding professional standards.
  12. Government must ensure the passage of the Broadcasting Bill.

Call for application: Journalism training on women empowerment and gender-sensitive reporting in Ghana, Cote D’Ivoire

Are you a passionate female journalist based in Ghana or Cote d’Ivoire?

Do you want to deepen your knowledge, understanding, and skills for more effective gender-sensitive reporting that contributes to women’s empowerment through your work?

Here is a unique opportunity for you!

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) with support from the French media development agency, Canal France International (CFI Medias), is excited to announce a four-day in-person training workshop on Women’s Empowerment and Gender-Sensitive reporting for female journalists including freelancers based in Ghana and Cote D’Ivoire.

Objective of training:

  • To equip female journalists including freelancers with the knowledge, skills, and tools necessary for more effective reporting on issues related to gender equality and women’s empowerment in the two target countries.

Target Group

  • We are seeking applications from female journalists including freelancers who demonstrate a strong commitment to promoting gender equality and have a track record of producing high-quality journalism. Participants will be selected based on their experience, motivation, and potential to contribute to the objectives of the training.

Date and Approach of Training Workshop

  • The training workshop is scheduled to take place in the last week of May 2024. It will combine both theory and practice as a method of delivery.
  • Beneficiaries will take part in individual story production, as well as group assignments and presentations.
  • Participants will also develop a post-training story production plan that can be monitored and will receive at least one month of post-training coaching from workshop trainers.

Application Process and Deadline:

  • Interested persons should apply via this link no later than May 5, 2024.

 Only short-listed applicants will be contacted.

MFWA to host forum on mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives on Ghana’s 2024 elections

Ghana’s democracy continues to show resilience, 32 years after the advent of its Fourth Republic. However, it remains a fact that every election year, the country’s peace architecture comes under significant stress as a result of spirals in intemperate language that directly stem from political campaigning.

Stakeholders agree that the escalation in the political temperature during election seasons is chiefly driven by misinformation, disinformation and propaganda by politicians, who amplify their toxic narratives through the media. As Ghana prepares to go to the polls in December 2024, it has become imperative that stakeholder efforts are made to tame the toxic narratives.

On March 27, 2024, the Media Foundation for West Africa will host a forum at the Accra International Conference Center (AICC) to put the issues in focus. It will be held under the theme: Countering Mis/Disinformation and Propaganda Narratives in the 2024 Elections in Ghana.

It is expected to bring together about 150 participants including governance and media experts, security analyst, legal experts, CSOs, public/state institutions, political parties, religious groups, journalists, the diplomatic community, and human rights activists.

Other participants will be members from the diplomatic community, religious groups and human academia.

Participants will deliberate on the phenomenon of mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives and their impact on the political discourse, media, peace, and security in Ghana.

They will also identify challenges, and proffer key recommendations on how the country can build resilience against mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives, as Ghana inches towards elections in December 2024.

The forum will be broadcast live on Joy FM and run from 9 am to 5pm.

 It forms part of an eight-month project that the MFWA has been implementing to build and strengthen the ecosystem for countering mis/disinformation with funding support from the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office.

As part of the project, 100 media practitioners across the country, including journalists and social media influencers, have been trained in fact-checking to enable them to spot and debunk mis/disinformation and propaganda narratives.

2023 ended with uptick in attacks as 4th Quarter recorded 9% rise in FOE violations

The MFWA’s monitoring report for the fourth quarter of 2023 demonstrates a concerning trend of government interference, attacks on journalists, legal harassment, and media censorship, amidst endemic impunity in the region.

A total of thirty-nine (39) incidents of freedom of expression violations were recorded. The figure is eight per cent (8%) higher than that of the preceding quarter (July-September 2023) which stood at 36.

Nigeria recorded twelve (12) violations, the highest number of violations during the quarter. Guinea followed with seven (7) violations, while Mali and Ghana recorded five (5) and four (4) violations respectively. Senegal and Sierra Leone recorded three (3) violations each. Burkina Faso and The Gambia each recorded two (2) violations, while Togo recorded one (1) violation.

The quarter was marred by a wave of arrests and detentions, physical attacks, and censorship in the subregion. The most serious incidents of violations occurred in Mali where a deadly attack on a convoy of journalists left one dead, another kidnapped and others injured. Another grievous violation was recorded in Guinea with the internet heavily restricted on social media platforms in the country.

In one of the numerous incidents in Nigeria, Major General Bello Mohammed Abdullahi, the Niger State Commissioner of Homeland Security, on November 24, 2023, assaulted Mustapha Batsari, a journalist with Voice of America (VOA). The altercation took place at the Government House in Minna where Batsari had gone to seek information from the Commissioner regarding a crisis in Beji, Bosso Local Government Area.

The following day, November 25, 2023, numerous media outlets in Guinea encountered disruptions, including jammed radio signals and the unavailability of popular social media platforms like WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok without a VPN. FIM FM and Djoma FM both reported signal interference on the same day.

In terms of distribution, twenty-five (25) of the violations were targeted at journalists and media workers, while nine (9) were targeted at media organisations. Four (4) of the violations were directed at citizens with one (1) targeted at an activist. Seven (7) different types of perpetrators were responsible for the thirty-nine (39) violations.

Security agents accounted for nineteen (19) violations, representing forty-nine per cent (49%) of the total. State/public officials and individuals carried out six (6) violations (15%) and seven (7) violations (18%) respectively. Political party affiliates, the courts and media regulatory bodies each accounted for two (2) violations (5%). The remaining violation was attributed to media owners/managers which recorded one violation (1) representing 3%.

This quarter’s freedom of expression monitor also features other important freedom of expression and digital rights developments in the region, including redresses for violations and recommendations to key stakeholders.

Access the full report here.

IWD2024: Pushing for newsroom policies and culture of equal opportunities for women

Globally, research shows that more women, than men, enrol into journalism schools and move on to pursue careers in the journalism vocation. However, it is their male counterparts who dominate senior editorial and managerial positions in many media organisations. This state of gender disparity within newsrooms, is partly what accounts for the dominant masculine news values that tilt media content in favour of men’s issues to the relegation of women’s issues.

The factors that continue to drive this gender disparity remain largely similar but tend to be nuanced under the influence of socio-cultural factors that differ from one region of the world to another. In West Africa, the drivers remain deeply ingrained cultural stereotypes that position women as better suited for more docile roles in newsrooms.

For instance, as research shows, there is a widespread perception that women are better suited for glamorous news anchoring roles, rather than investigative journalism duties. And in television, women tend to have their value measured more in terms of their physical looks and appearance than skill and qualification, the research reported.

But these stereotypes are really, just what they are – stereotypes; because in spite of all of these barriers, women journalists keep proving themselves very capable of the demands of journalism, irrespective of variety or style. And for the few female journalists who have broken through the glass ceiling to occupy editorial and managerial roles of media organisations, their stories and triumphs remain compelling examples; this is whether it is Ifeyinwa Omowole, Editor-in-chief of the Nigeria News Agency, Khadija Patel, chairperson of the International Press Institute and former editor-in-chief of the Mail & Guardian, or Jamila Akweley Okertchiri, first female editor of the Daily Guide newspaper in Ghana.

On the occasion of the International Women’s Day, the theme – ‘Invest in Women: Accelerate Progress,’ is a fitting call to action. For stakeholders in media, it provides stimulus to advance activism that confronts the existing gendered stereotypes that antagonise women in newsrooms.  This call to action invites stakeholders to once more galvanize and make another push for the cause to achieve newsrooms that offer equal career opportunities to women, just as it offers to men.

This is not to imply that there has been lack of activism and progress in the fight for gender equity in newsrooms in West Africa; many stakeholders have long been at work confronting gender disparity by means of various strategies. At the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA), for instance, the strategies have included various forms of journalism training programmes in which a standard requirement is that at least 40% of the beneficiaries are female. An example of an empowerment programme in which this requirement is applied is the MFWA’s Next Generation Investigative Journalism (NGIJ) Fellowship.

In addition, the MFWA also undertakes regular training programmes on issues such as fact-checking, data journalism and mobile journalism for beneficiaries, 40% of whom must be women.

But even with interventions such as those by the MFWA, room still remains for a lot more to be done. West African governments have been particularly notorious for being slow adopters of gender equity policies and even where they do adopt such, implementation is often shambolic. As research has long confirmed that women catalyse development, these lackadaisical attitudes by governments must change in all regards, including, in the adoption and implementation of policies that create equity for women in all contours of the macro and micro economic value chain.

Governments should not only implement gender equity policies but should be seen to be doing so as such actions on the part of governments are powerful for conscientizing citizens on the need for gender equity.

Civil society is definitely to be commended for the years of investment in, and activism for gender parity in West Africa, but the theme for this year’s commemoration of International Women’s Day is a further call on CSOs to not fall back but to renew commitment to the cause of gender equity.

For media organisations, this commemoration should galvanize resolve to intentionally make newsrooms more equitable, while for women journalists themselves, the challenge is to assert their value as journalists who are as capable as their male counterparts.

Meanwhile, the call to action should also be seen as a challenge to ECOWAS to do more for the enhancement of women’s rights. In this regard, a more aggressive fostering of the ECOWAS Treaty for gender equality, under Article 63, is imperative.

Director of TV station survives brutal stabbing attack

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) strongly condemns the brazen assault on Maïmouna Ndour Faye, director of the television station 7TV, and urges the government to expedite investigations leading to the arrest of the perpetrator.

On February 29, 2024, Senegal was shocked by a violent attack on Maïmouna Ndour Faye, owner of the Dakar-based 7TV outside her home. The assailant, who remains unidentified, ambushed her, stabbing her multiple times and dragging her on several metres before leaving her unconscious and covered in blood.

The gruesome incident occurred in the evening, shortly after Maïmouna Ndour Faye’s regular programme with Farba Ngom, a Member of Parliament and head of propaganda for the ruling party, the Alliance pour la République (APR).

Fortunately, initial medical assessments indicated that Maïmouna Ndour Faye’s injuries are not life-threatening, and she is responding to treatment. Ibrahima Lissa Faye, head of the press union Coordination des Associations de Presse (CAP), and 7TV news presenter Mamadou Awa Ndiaye confirmed her condition.

The assault has sparked widespread condemnation from journalists, civil society members, and politicians, who have unanimously denounced it as “cowardly” and “despicable.”

President Macky Sall condemned the violence, emphasising that “Press freedom is a fundamental right that must be protected and respected in all circumstances. No form of violence can be tolerated, and those responsible for this attack will have to answer for their actions before the courts.”

In the same statement on the social media platform X, he reaffirmed his commitment to creating a safe environment for media professionals in the country.

“This country has been drifting towards a dangerous slope for some years now with a tendency to impose one-track thinking. Those of us who host political broadcasts are insulted and threatened all day long. Today, intellectuals and some politicians are avoiding public discourse,” lamented Mamadou Awa Ndiaye, a colleague of Mame Faye, who spoke to the MFWA via a messaging App.

Prominent journalist and social justice activist, Mame Diarra Diarra Ndiaye, expressed deep outrage over the brutal attack on Madame Maimouna Ndour Faye in Senegal at the beginning of Women’s History Month on March 1, 2024. As International Women’s Day approached, she called for solidarity and action against the culture of impunity and violence. Justice was demanded not only for Madame Ndour Faye but also for all victims of police violence, arbitrary arrests, and silenced voices.

Several other voices condemned what they termed a criminal act and expressed their solidarity with her.

Karim Wade declared that “the attack against Maimouna Ndour Faye is an attack against everyone”, underlining the importance of supporting the victim.

Candidate Amadou BA’s campaign management denounced this “violent attack” and called for the culprits to be sought out and punished, saying that this act was “unacceptable in a leading democracy.”

The Khalifa Président Coalition also strongly condemned the attack, denouncing “a level of intolerance that is rampant in our society” and expressing its solidarity with Maimouna Ndour Faye.

The Diomaye Président coalition wished the journalist well and also condemned the brutal attack.

The Minister of the Interior, Sidiki Kaba, visited the victim and called the act “despicable”, ordering the relevant services to seek out and apprehend the perpetrators.

The Minister for Communication, Moussa Bocar Thiam, strongly condemned the attack, describing it as “a despicable act and an attempted murder”, and gave assurances that the State would do everything in its power to identify the culprits.

Finally, human rights organisations also expressed their indignation and called for an investigation to bring the perpetrators to justice. These include organisations such as the Ligue Sénégalaise des Droits de l’Homme (LSDH), ARTICLE 19 Sénégal et Afrique de l’Ouest, Amnesty International Sénégal, the Rencontre Africaine pour la Défense des Droits de l’Homme (RADDHO), AfrikaJom Center and AfricTivistes.

The CAP labelled the attack as an “act of unacceptable barbarism” and expressed concerns about recurring attacks, particularly against women journalists. It pledged to support Maimouna Ndour Faye in her legal efforts to ensure that the culprits are apprehended and punished.

The MFWA is appalled by the brutal attempted murder of Maïmouna Ndour Faye, and reiterates its call for swift investigations leading to the arrest of the culprits. While urging the Senegalese state to be more diligent for the safety of Maimouna and all other journalists, we urge all journalists to be more cautious in the field.

Closure of 4 radio stations in Bawku: The wrong approach to doing the right thing

0

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) welcomes as a step in the right direction the decision to shut down four radio stations in the conflict-stricken Bawku Municipality, in the Upper East Region of Ghana.

The National Communications Authority (NCA), one of Ghana’s media regulators, announced on February 24, 2024, that it has closed four broadcast stations, namely Bawku FM, Source FM, Zahra FM and Gumah FM, “on grounds of national security.”

“This follows the recommendations of the Upper East Regional Security Council, and on the advice of the Ministry of National Security that the operations of the said FM Stations and the incendiary utterances of their panellists/presenters have contributed to the escalation of the Bawku conflict, leading to loss of lives and property in Bawku and its environs,” the NCA’s statement said.

Having monitored the media in Bawku over some time, we have witnessed and can confirm the inflammable, rabble-rousing pronouncements that the NCA is citing as the reason for its decision. In fact, in September 2022, we participated in a virtual forum of media stakeholders convened by the National Media Commission (NMC), the other media regulator, to discuss and make recommendations on the increasing recklessness of certain radio stations in Bawku.

Subsequent to this meeting, the NMC on October 2, 2022, issued a press release warning the owners of the stations involved “to adopt stronger gatekeeping measures to ensure that persons with interests in the conflict do not hijack radio stations to foment trouble.”

The NMC also requested all radio stations in Bawku to submit to the Commission clear measures they have put in place to ensure professionalism in the radio stations. The Commission went on to advise stations that faced capacity challenges to approach the MFWA and the Ghana Independent Broadcasters’ Association (GIBA) for assistance to enhance their gatekeeping systems and professional standards, as agreed during the said stakeholders meeting.

Against the above background, the closure of the four stations does have some reasonable basis. While the decision might be right, the MFWA is of the view that the closures should not have been carried out by the NCA which has no power to enforce ethics and professional standards and is, therefore, not the appropriate body to issue sanctions over media content. That role lies with the NMC.

The NCA’s action, which the Authority seeks to justify under Section 13(1)(e) of the Electronic Communications Act, 2008 (Act 775), amounts to claiming concurrent powers with the NMC over broadcast content regulation. It is our contention that the NCA’s power to revoke or suspend broadcast licenses under this law relates to breaches of a technical nature, such as diversion or misuse of frequency by radio or television license holders for activities liable to undermine national security or public interest.

As the media regulator and arbiter of conflicts involving the media, the National Media Commission is insulated from external influence. Article 172 of the Constitution says:

Except as otherwise provided by this Constitution or by any other law not inconsistent with this Constitution, the National Media Commission shall not be subject to the direction or control of any person or authority in the performance of its functions.

The National Communications Authority, on the other hand, is an agency of the Ministry of Communications, operating under the control and direction of a Minister with partisan interest. The Board of Directors of the NCA, Director-General and Deputy Directors-General are political appointees who are beholden to the President and his political party.

It is, therefore, a dangerous precedent for the NCA and the National Security Ministry, both run by persons with partisan interests, to be clothed with the power to sanction broadcast stations for their content.

The action of the NCA in concert with the National Security Ministry without recourse to the NMC could pavé the way for future autocratic governments to embark on politically-motivated targeting of broadcast media organisations using the National Security, whose intelligence claims cannot be questioned by the public.

In view of this, we recommend a review of the Electronic Communications Act 2008 (Act 775) and the National Media Commission Act 1993 (Act 449) to transfer the broadcast frequency allocation and licensing function of the NCA to the NMC to completely insulate the broadcasting sector from possible political meddling.

We are privy to and do deplore the reckless broadcasting by some stations in Bawku and do recognise the danger they pose to the peace-building efforts in the area.  Their closure is, therefore, a decision in the right direction. Nonetheless, we maintain, as a matter of principle, that it was carried out by the wrong institution. We might not always get it right if we allow State Security and the NCA to get into the arena of sanctioning media outlets over their content.

Absence of docket on Ahmed Suale’s murder case shows government indifference

The disclosure by Ghana’s Attorney-General and Minister of justice, Godfred Yeboah Dame, that his office has received no docket on the murder of Ahmed Suale, is the utmost proof of the state’s lack of commitment to solving the case.

“No docket or document fit for prosecution has been built and presented to my office since the murder”, the Minister said on February 20, 2024.

Ahmed Suale was murdered five years ago. A lack of progress report on the investigations had persuaded MPs in Ghana’s parliament, to demand an update and it was in response to this that the AG had appeared before the lawmakers.

 “On being appointed Attorney General, the former Inspector General of Police [James] Oppong-Boanuh paid a courtesy call on me on March 29, 2021, for being concerned about the failure to resolve this case and other cases.

“I inquired about the state of investigations into the matter and demanded a report on the case and the director general of CID obliged,” Godfred Dame said during his appearance.

It is troubling because the parts of the Attorney General’s statement about his discussion with the former IGP, came across as rehearsed. This is the second time the Attorney General has made these same pronouncements before the august House in response to the lack of prosecution on the Suale murder case. The first was on July 27, 2021, when he was giving an update on the killing of the investigative journalist and other high-profile killings, including those of Ekow Hayford and J. B. Danquah Adu, former MPs for Mfantseman and Abuakwa North, respectively. Mr. Dame told Parliament at that time that his office had received no docket on the Ahmed Suale case and that he had raised the issue with the Inspector-General of Police (IGP) when the latter had paid a courtesy call on him on March 29, 2021.

“Being concerned about the failure to resolve this and other homicide cases, I enquired about the state of investigations into the same. I emphasised to the IGP and his team the need to conclude investigations for action to be taken as soon as practically possible,” he had said.

The presentation of this recycled information in 2024, raises suspicion that since the 2021 meeting with the IGP, the AG has been sleeping on the Suale case but was suddenly jolted by the demand for an update by the MPs. And then, Mr. Godfred Yeboah Dame scrambled and went off to rehearse his 2021 statement for Parliament once more.

In a seeming attempt to placate MPs over the lack of prosecution, the AG asked for more patience, likening the delay around the Suale case to the about the 29 years that the murder of American rapper, Tupac Shakur, had remained unsolved since his shooting in 2006 until 2023.

Meanwhile, as if the delayed justice is not disheartening enough, the principal legal officer of the state went on to suggest that the killing of Suale may be unconnected to his journalism work. This amounts to beating the media and denying them the right to cry, given the well-documented events leading to the attack on Ahmed Suale.

“The killing of Suale on the heels of the Number 12 football corruption expose and following a campaign inciting the public to attack the journalist establish solid prima facie grounds to link the murder to his work. Whoever claims otherwise must prove the contrary,” said Muheeb Saeed, Head of Freedom of Expression at the MFWA.

Mr. Dame’s attempt to disconnect Ahmed Suale’s killing from his work contrasts starkly with the world’s reaction to the killing of renowned Dutch journalist, Peter R. de Vries.

For instance, the Director-General of UNESCO, Audrey Azoulay, commended the crime reporter’s “relentless commitment to the profession, and eagerness to unveil the truth”, adding “I trust that the authorities will bring the perpetrators of this heinous crime to justice, to show that neither the right to free expression nor the course of justice can be obstructed through violence.”

The AG’s revelation that there is no prosecutable docket only undermines the confidence of the media and the public in President Akufo-Addo to deliver justice in this matter before he leaves office, as he promised a little over a year ago.

“I continue to be deeply regretful that despite the unceasing best effort of the police, the perpetrators of the murder of Ahmed Suale can still not be found. But I assure you that, so far as I remain President, the dossier cannot be closed until they are brought to justice,” the President had said during the Ghana Journalists’ Association (GJA’s) dinner on December 21, 2022.

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) is highly disappointed in the Attorney-General’s empty update before Parliament. This recycled presentation demonstrates a flagrant indifference to the case and we wholly deplore it.

The MFWA also reiterates it disappointment with the inability of the police and the state security apparatus to provide evidence of any serious work towards tracking down the murderers of Ahmed Suale. As a nation, we may have been taken unawares by the criminals who perpetrated the murder, but if that can be excused, there is no excuse for lack of action to ensure redress and, thereby, redeem ourselves. We therefore urge Parliament to continue to exert pressure on the government to act on this matter. We also herby call on all media stakeholders to convene a meeting to explore all avenues that could help end impunity over the murder of Ahmed Suale.