Home Blog Page 25

International Women’s Day 2021: MFWA Challenges Governments to Address Women’s Rights Online Issues

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) celebrates women in Ghana and across the West Africa region for the gallant roles they continue to play at the local, national, and international levels, most especially during the COVID-19 outbreak.

In particular, the MFWA congratulates all the women who have put their lives on the line as frontline health workers and caregivers to save lives, and as journalists to keep the public informed about the pandemic, even at the peak of the outbreak.

The COVID-19 pandemic undoubtedly exposed the challenges and inequalities women continue to face in both offline and online spaces as Women were the worst hit by the devastating effects of the COVID-19 outbreak.

This became starker when the COVID-19 situation pushed a lot of offline activities and engagements into the online world as a result of safety measures and movement restrictions put in place by various governments to contain the spread of the virus.

Unfortunately, many women in Ghana and West Africa remain offline as a result of challenges, including access, affordability, digital literacy, online harassment, as highlighted in a Report Card produced by the Web Foundation and the MFWA. Thus, while the world practically moved into an online society, many women in the region were left behind, thereby losing out on business opportunities and services that were critical to their survival and economic empowerment.

Girls also received their fair share of the impact of COVID-19 as technology became the centre of education due to the fact that schools were closed and learning activities and lessons were moved online. Many girls, including those in the urban and most especially those in the rural areas were left out as they did not have digital access and skills.

In line with the theme for the 2021 International Women’s Day (#ChooseToChallenge), the MFWA is choosing to challenge Governments in West Africa, to provide the enabling environment for gender-equitable access to the internet and other ICTs.

In Ghana, the MFWA, with funding support from the Web Foundation has undertaken a mapping of selected policy documents to identify the gaps that need to be filled to ensure that women can access and use the internet and other ICTs.

Among other things, the soon-to-be-launched report highlights provision of gender-disaggregated data as one of the major challenges in policies. This makes it difficult to measure progress towards bridging the digital-gender divide. Funding to implement some of the policies that could enhance women’s participation in online spaces is also another major challenge identified, and so is the lack of/ inadequate provision for sensitisation in many of the policies.

The organisation is, therefore, challenging government to demonstrate its commitment to closing up the digital gender gap by adopting the recommendations made in the Baseline Report on Women’s Rights Online Issues in Ghana and the five-point Action Plan proposed in the Report Card on Ghana.

As an organisation, the MFWA will continue to promote women’s rights online as part of its Digital Rights Programme. We remain committed to engaging the relevant stakeholders and training women’s rights groups, journalists, and bloggers to empower them to support the advocacy and to contribute to the creation of relevant online content that speaks to the needs of women and girls in Ghana and the rest of West Africa.

The International Women’s Day is celebrated every March 8.

Senegal Protests: 2 Demonstrators Killed, TV Channels Suspended, Radio Office Ransacked

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) condemns the disruption of social networks in Senegal, the suspension of two television channels as well as the deadly repression of protests.

While also denouncing the violent demonstrators, who attacked other media outlets, the MFWA calls on the Senegalese authorities to ensure that freedom of the press is protected, that media on all sides are safe and independent in their reporting.

On Friday 5th March 2021 morning, network data from the NetBlocks, an organisation that monitors internet and social network access, revealed a mobile internet disruption at the major phone companies Orange and Sonatel in Senegal.

“Metrics show that Facebook, YouTube, WhatsApp, and some Telegram servers were restricted on leading cellular network operator Orange/Sonatel as of early morning Friday. Affected services have subsequently been restored from 7:30 a.m. UTC.” had published NetBlocks.

However, the reason for the observed disruptions has not been ascertained, as neither the cellular network operators nor the public authorities have issued an official statement to this effect. However, evidence shows that an increasing number of governments on the continent are resorting to internet blackouts and blocking of social networks to suppress anti-government protests and restrict online civil and political space.

Earlier, on 3 March 2021, demonstrations broke out in Dakar, the capital of Senegal, and in several other major cities in the country such as Kaolack, Saint Louis, and Casamance. Demonstrations persisted on 4 March. The protests resulted from the arrest of Ousmane Sonko, leader of the opposition political party Patriotes du Sénégal pour le Travail, l’Ethique et la Fraternité́, (Pastef-Patriotes), a deputy in the National Assembly and third in the 2019 presidential elections.

As he was on his way to court to respond to a rape complaint, Ousmane Sonko had been arrested for “disturbing public order and participating in an unauthorised demonstration”.

At least two people were killed by anti-riot forces during the violent repression of demonstrations against Sonko’s arrest. The police and gendarmerie used batons, tear gas, and live ammunition to disperse demonstrators. Sheikh Ibrahima Coly and Sheikh Diop, aged 20 and 17 respectively, died from gunshot wounds.

Other demonstrators were arrested, several others were injured and there was extensive damage to properties. The authorities have not yet released official figures on arrests and the results of the law-enforcement agencies’ repression.

Nevertheless, the Minister of the Interior, Antoine Félix Abdoulaye Diome, had justified the arrest of Ousmane Sonko on the grounds of the ban on gatherings issued because of the Covid-19 and a traffic plan put in place by the authorities.

Also, on 4 March 2021, the broadcasting regulatory authority, the Conseil National de Régulation de l’Audiovisuel (CNRA) suspended two private television channels, WALF TV and SEN TV, for three days on account of broadcasting a loop of violent images.

These two media are considered to be close to the opposition and they are accused by the CNRA of stirring up violence. However, besides the 2STV, the CNRA had warned two other private channels against broadcasting content that “explicitly or implicitly promotes violence”, incites disturbances of public order, or “is likely to constitute a threat to national stability or social cohesion”.

Media outlets considered to be close to the authorities were also targeted by angry demonstrators. The state media outlet Soleil and two other private media, RFM and Dakaractu, were targeted by demonstrators.

While condemning the disruption of social networks in Senegal, the suspension of the two television channels as well as attacks by demonstrators on other media, the MFWA calls on authorities to probe into the deadly repression made by law enforcement officials and punish the perpetrators.

The organisation also calls on political parties to sensitise their supporters on the need for peaceful demonstrations, which is essential for any democracy, and for the respect of press and journalists’ rights to do their job of informing the public. As Senegal is considered a model of democracy in the sub-region, sanctioning the media under the pretext of “state security” or attacking them for their supposed political sides promises nothing good for the credibility of civil and political freedoms. These attacks call into question the democratic culture that the country has acquired. Violating these democratic values as well as the freedom of expression and of the press, is a dangerous precedent for the country and West Africa. This further has the potential to galvanise other countries that are not yet completely divorced from the remnants of authoritarian rule.

Therefore, the Media Foundation for West Africa urges public authorities, law enforcement agencies, and opposition political parties to take the necessary steps to assuage political tensions.

MFWA Calls on Media to Reject Autocratic Order from Judicial Service of Ghana

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) totally rejects the order from the Judicial Service of Ghana to media organisations to take down all online stories that the service deemed insulting to the judiciary. The Foundation considers the order a frontal attack on press freedom.

Ghanaians are generally decent people who accord due respect to their democratic institutions, including the judiciary. Anytime such institutions have come under unwarranted attack, this collective sense of decency and respect for democratic order have galvanized the public to denounce such attacks in the most robust and emphatic manner. In this case, we dare say, that even in our divided opinions about the Supreme Court’s handling of the Election Petition, the public does not seem to agree that said publications have crossed any red lines.

The Judicial Service’s view of critical publications as insulting and liable to undermine the image and authority of the judiciary is, in our view, exaggerated.

The order to media houses to “pull or cause to be pulled down and cleared from your platforms, all statements and speeches which convey and/or insinuate hateful, spiteful, vengeful, and incendiary communication against Justices” of the Courts amounts to interference in the editorial judgement of media house and an infringement on the freedom and independence of the media.

We are concerned that the Judicial Service is asking media houses to “prevent the publication of such statements and speeches on your platforms, and forthwith exercise the highest level of discernment, discretion and responsibility insofar as the publication of statements and speeches regarding the administration of justice are concerned.”

This is a direct order with an authoritative tone that would be unsettling even in an autocracy. This is a call on media houses to self-censor and censor critical opinions about the judiciary, which is unacceptable in a democratic country such as Ghana.

The freedom of the media is guaranteed by the Constitution of Ghana and is supposed to be independent and free from censorship and external interference. The media, as an institution, is obliged to uphold the responsibility and accountability of the Government to the people of Ghana as spelt out in Article 162 (1,2,4&5 of the 1992 constitution).

This is not to suggest, however, that the media cannot err or is above the law. Journalists and media organisations are subject to the constitution, which has provided for the National Media Commission (NMC) as responsible for enforcing ethics, promoting professionalism, and sanctioning infringement of media ethics.

We would, therefore, have thought that the Judicial Service would lodge its grievances, if any, with the NMC, and institution meant to mediate and check reckless journalism that could injure the reputation and or interests of individuals and institutions.

The order from the Judicial Service is a flagrant interference in the editorial independence of the media houses concerned and an attempt at censorship. The MFWA, therefore, calls on the media to disregard it and to help sustain Ghana’s democracy by continuing to report and discuss, according to their conscience and within the limits of the law and the code of ethics, the work of the judiciary, and to hold all public institutions accountable to the people.

MFWA Board Saddened by Impact of COVID-19 on Media Businesses, Bemoans Worsening Human Rights Conditions in Guinea

The Board of Directors of the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) has expressed deep concerns about the devastating impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on media businesses in West Africa.

At its recent meeting on February 25, 2021, the Board bemoaned the collapse of several media organisations in the region and the consequent job losses in the media sector. Since the outbreak of the pandemic, over 100 media organisations in the region have folded up with hundreds of journalists losing their jobs as a result.

As the crises from the pandemic persist, it remains uncertain how many more media organisations in the region will become casualties to the serious economic and other challenges caused by the pandemic. The Board, thus, urged governments and other stakeholders in the region to take steps to support the survival and sustainability of the media in the various countries.

The Board also denounced the continuous and escalating spate of human and media rights violations in the Republic of Guinea. Over the last two years, dozens of journalists and other human rights activists have been attacked, arrested and detained, and others even killed. The Board called on the government of Guinea to take immediate and appropriate steps to end the spate of violations and also provide justice for victims.

These, among other concerns, were contained in a six-point Resolution adopted by the Board after its meeting.  Below is the six-point Resolution adopted by the Board:

Resolution by the Board of Directors of Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) At its Meeting held on February 25, 2021

 On February 25, 2021, the Board of Directors of the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) held a virtual meeting to discuss a number of strategic documents and issues; the implications and impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the regional context and operations of the organisation; and other broader issues of media freedom, freedom of expression and media development in West Africa. The meeting was presided over by the Chairperson of the Board, Ms. Sophie Ly Sow of Senegal. At the end of the meeting, the Board unanimously adopted and issued this six-point Resolution.

  1. The Board is deeply concerned about the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on nearly every aspect of life and in particular, the crippling effect of the pandemic on media businesses and media sustainability in the region. The Board also acknowledges the further deterioration of press freedom, freedom of expression and the continuous shrinking of civic spaces in the region, which has been exacerbated by COVID-19-related attacks and repressive policies. It, therefore, called on governments in the region to offer stimulus support to media organisations to enhance their capacity so they can continue to operate even under the challenging economic circumstances.
  1. The Board is deeply saddened by the fact that increasingly, a few countries in the region that served as champions for press freedom and free expression, are ceasing their leadership role on those issues and called for the resurgence of regional leadership on press freedom and freedom of expression issues. In this regard, the Board welcomed recent commitments by a number of governments around the World to re-energise efforts on promoting media freedom and safety of journalists around the world.
  1. The Board reiterates its deep concern about the serious and systematic human and media rights violations in the Republic of Guinea and urges authorities in the country to take immediate steps to address such violations and provide justice for victims. In view of the situation, the Board directed that the organisation should plan and execute a dedicated advocacy campaign on the situation in Guinea and to work with the government and other stakeholders to help improve the state of media rights and freedom of expression in the country.
  1. In the light of general deteriorating human rights conditions in the region, the Board notes with profound sadness, the decision by the governments of Cote d’Ivoire and Benin to withdraw the right of individuals and Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) to submit complaints directly to the African Court of Human and People Right (AfCHPR). The Board expressed concern that the decision of the two governments has the potential to further impede citizens’ access to justice and also reverse the modest gains made in the promotion of human rights in the region.
  1. Recognising the importance of technology to the overall development and in the efforts to bring the COVID-19 pandemic under control in the region, the Board emphasised the importance of internet access, affordability and use by all, but especially by women. Accordingly, the Board calls on national governments and regional bodies in West Africa to prioritise investments in ICTs and work collaboratively to promote internet freedom and especially women’s digital rights, to help bridge the widening digital gender gap in the region.
  1. The Board remains extremely concerned about the serious challenges posed by extremism, terrorism and drug trafficking to the overall security situation in the region and in particular, to media freedom and practice in West Africa. The Board thus, calls on national governments and regional bodies to work collaboratively to help address the problem.

 

Adopted, this Thursday February 25, 2021.

Mitigating the COVID-19 Impact: Six Media Organisations in West Africa Supported to Improve Online Presence, Revenue Generation

COVID-19 wreaked a devastating impact on the media in West Africa. The pandemic, at its peak in 2020, posed a serious challenge to revenue streams of media organisations. Advertising cuts and less spending by media consumers worsened the already precarious sustainability crisis facing the region’s media. Many media organisations laid off staff and cut down on production. Some were forced to adopt emergent austerity measures while looking for alternate sources of funding. Media organisations redesigned their newsrooms and how news was gathered, processed, and disseminated; others, completely shutdown.

Restrictions and lifestyle changes of media consumers instigated a significant shift towards online media with a heavy reliance on the Internet and digital tools for media work. Interestingly, Online media outlets experienced spikes in visits and the prospects of improved revenue in the online space. For example, in Senegal, leading online news platform Seneweb, “saw the number of visitors on their website increased by 30% on average” while MediaForce-Afrique and International Centre for Investigative Reporting in Senegal and Nigeria respectively witnessed massive surge in the number of visitors to their sites.

Legacy media, on the other hand, was the most devastated. Many of them had had some online presence (websites; social media handles) prior to COVID; but only a few, had been minded and actually invested in the potential of the digital/online space to grow their visibility and revenue in the long run.

Giving the immeasurable prospects for improved revenue and viability, especially in the face of COVID-19, the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) supported six influential media organisations in five countries in West Africa to adopt new digital tools aimed at improving their online presence, audience reach and revenue generation. The beneficiary media organisations are A1 radio and Skyy Power FM based in Ghana; The Daily Observer in Liberia; Eburnie Today in Cote d’Ivoire, La Maison des Reporters in Senegal, and Banouto in Benin.

The MFWA financially supported the beneficiary media organisations to engage the services of digital media Consultants who assessed their online platforms – website and social media – and recommended best tools and practices to improve their presence online. This was complemented by an in-house training for a period of two weeks during which staff of the media organisations were introduced to digital marketing concepts and tools such as brand identity; creating digital videos; setting up a digital-savvy newsroom and how to use social media to effectively engage and communicate with audience. The beneficiary media organisations also received a virtual post-training coaching from the Consultants for at least three months.

In Ghana, A1 radio, a leading private radio station in Bolgatanga, the country’s Upper East region, following the support, has launched a new website with digital features to feed its audience. It has also created a 10-minute local news programme that reports local content from the five Northern regions in Ghana. The station has also improved its visitor ratings according to U.S-based Alexa.com (web traffic analysis company) from 2,010th in December 2020, to be among the first 700 in January 2021.

One of Liberia’s leading private newspaper, The Daily Observer, a member of the Liberian Observer Corporation, was one of the worst hit by the pandemic. Newspaper sales in 2020 dwindled by a record 50% according to Bai Sama Best, General Manager of the Corporation. Following the institutional support from the MFWA, the media organisation has re-strategised and prioritized its website content production/management and constituted a core online team to manage the organisation’s online platforms and presence.

Prior to MFWA’s support, online media organisation in Senegal, La Maison des Reporters, did not have a digital media strategy. Maison des Reporters is developing a digital strategy to guide and boost its online presence and begin generating revenue from the website.

In February 2019, Banouto media, one of the beneficiaries of the MFWA media sustainability project in Benin was adjudged the number one most visited online information site in Benin by New York-based internet giant, SimilarWeb.

The MFWA’s Media Institutional Capacity Building Support makes available both financial and technical support to media organisations in West Africa to improve their content and viability. So far about 10 major media organisations have been supported including Ghana-based Citi TV/FM and Sierra Leone-based AYV. The project is implemented with funding support from the Open Society Initiative for West Africa (OSIWA).

Video Story: Ghanaian MPs Reference MFWA Data in Questioning Ministers on Press Freedom

Members of Ghana’s Parliament confronted two Ministers-Designate using data from the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) on key issues of press freedom that have been raised consistently by the MFWA over the last couple of years.

This was done during the vetting (confirmation hearing) of the two Ministers-Designate who have been re-nominated by the President of Ghana for the portfolios of Communication and Digitisation; and Information. Both Ministers-Designate had been Ministers for the same sectors in the last four years.

First to appear before the Appointment Committee of Parliament on February 16, 2021, was the Minister-Designate for Communication and Digitisation, Ursula Owusu-Ekuful. She was specifically questioned on the closure of several radio stations in the country during her tenure as Minister with statements and letters published by the MFWA on the issues.

The MFWA has consistently condemned the closure of the stations as arbitrary and politically motivated giving that many of the stations that were closed were known to be aligned with the main opposition party. The MFWA has subsequently engaged with the National Communications Authority (NCA), which regulates the spectrum, and actually undertook the exercise to close down the radio stations for clarity on the matter.

During the Appointment Committee hearing, the Minister-Designate was confronted on the shutdown of the radio stations and the concerns raised by the MFWA. Below is the engagement where the Minority Chief Whip, Mohammed-Mubarak Muntaka, questioned the Minister-Designate about the shutdowns using MFWA’s publications. It ends with the Minister promising to investigate the issues and submitting a report to Parliament.

 

Earlier, the Ranking Member of Parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee, Samuel Okudzeto Ablakwa, read out portions of statements and letters that had been written by the MFWA on the shutdown of the radio stations to point out the issue of discrimination in closing down the stations. Below is the engagement between the Ranking Member and the Minister-Designate:

 

On 19th February, 2021, it was the turn of the Minister-Designate for Information. The Minister-Designate was presented with press freedom violation data compiled by the MFWA and asked what steps he will take to improve media freedom in the country. Below is the engagement with the Minister-Designate on the MFWA data:

Beninois Journalist Released from Detention Visits MFWA in Accra to Say “Thank You”

Following his release from prison, Beninois journalist Ignace Sossou paid what he called a “thank you visit” to the offices of the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) at East Legon, Accra, on February 19, 2020.

After a warm “elbow-shake” as the COVID-19 protocols will allow, the journalist who was imprisoned in 2019 in connection with his work, told the MFWA’s Executive Director that he had come to express gratitude and show appreciation to the MFWA for its role in getting him released from prison.

“I cannot thank the MFWA enough for the consistent advocacy you embarked on which contributed to my successful appeal and subsequent release from detention. The prison conditions were terrible, but your fight on my behalf, alongside the efforts of other press freedom organisations, always kept my spirit up,” the journalist said

Sossou, who works with Benin Web TV, was arrested at his home on December 20, 2019 by agents of the central office for the suppression of cybercrime and brought before a court, which sentenced him to 18 months in prison on December 24, 2019.

His arrest and conviction followed complaint from Benin’s Public Prosecutor that the journalist, who was covering a conference, had, in a tweet and a Facebook post, taken his words out of context.

Following Sossou’s imprisonment, the MFWA initiated many actions, including a joint petition with its national partner organisations, for the release of Ignace Sossou. We also joined many international human rights organisations to put pressure on the authorities in Benin to obtain the unconditional release of the journalist.

On March 24, 2020, which was exactly three months after Sossou was arrested, the MFWA again issued a statement calling on the beniniois authorities to end the unjust detention of the journalist.

On April 28, 2020, when the journalist was appearing in court for a hearing, MFWA and seven other press freedom organisations issued a statement calling on the Beninois authorities to release him particularly in view of the risk of infection by COVID-19 during his detention.

On 3 May, MFWA and its national partners sent a petition to the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Access to Information of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (ACHPR), Lawrence Mute, urging him to intervene in the case to secure the journalist’s release.

The pressure from freedom of expression organisations including MFWA contributed to the Court of Appeal commuting the sentence to 12 months, with 6 months suspended. He was finally released on June 24, 2020.

The grateful journalist decided to call at the offices of the MFWA to show appreciation for the organisation’s advocacy efforts which pressurised the Beninois authorities to shave 12 months off his 18-month sentence.

The Executive Director of the MFWA, Sulemana Braimah, praised the journalist for his fortitude and tenacity. He used the opportunity to express concern about the increasing exploitation of cyber-related laws to clamp down on online journalism and activism.

Media Ethics: Ghanaweb.com Tops as Incidence of Violations Double

News website Ghanaweb.com recorded more than 50% of the media ethics violations recorded for the period of February 1-15. The violations recorded on the popular news website were mostly unsavory and unprintable comments by readers of the online portal which the editors have allowed to be published.

Ghanaweb.com recorded 58 violations out of the 108 violations recorded for the period of monitoring. The violation recorded for the period represents exactly a 100% increase compared with the previous period of monitoring, January 16-31, where 54 violations were recorded.

These findings were observed by the Ethics Monitoring Project of the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) which monitored 26 news organisations made up of 10 Akan language radio stations, 10 newspapers, and six news websites. A total of 980 pieces of content from the 26 organisations were monitored and analysed out of which 108 ethical violations were recorded.

Aside from Ghanaweb.com which recorded 58 violations, modernghana.com also recorded 1 violation, making news websites the media outlet that infracted media ethics the most for the period of monitoring. Radio stations followed with 49 violations. The newspapers monitored did not record any violation for the period.

The monitoring of media ethics is part of a project titled: Enhancing Media Professionalism To Inspire Public Confidence and Support for Press Freedom in Ghana being implemented with funding support from the Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. The objective of the project is to identify and highlight incidents of ethical infractions and draw attention to such breaches as a way of fostering adherence to ethical principles by media organisations.

The full report contains the specific ethical principles violated, the names of the media outlets that committed the violations, among other findings. Click here to access the full report. The instrument being used for the monitoring, which contains the category definitions for tracking and reporting of ethical principles is also available here.

For further clarifications and media interviews, contact the Programme Manager, Abigail Larbi-Odei (0244867047), or Programme Officer, Kwaku Krobea Asante (0249484528).

Three Journalists Arrested, Critical Local Chief Summoned

Three journalists, Charles Kponwadan of the news website Horizon, Anani Vidzraku of Radio Victoire and Romuald Lansou of the Togoinfos web TV were arrested on February 3, 2021 and taken to the premises of the Golfe District Office by gendarmes for interviewing a very critical chief “without authorization”.

They were interviewing Togbui Dagban-Ayivon IV, head of the Adakpamé district (south-east of Lomé), who had just emerged from a hearing with the Head of the Golfe District, Komlan Agbotsè. Togbui Dagban-Ayivon IV, very regular on private radio stations to denounce the excesses of the government, had just left the hearing after being summoned by the district head .

Komlan Agbotsè called in a gendarme on duty inside the district office, who questioned the journalists before leading them to the waiting room. The bodyguard of Komlan Agbotsè then seized the working materials of the three journalists as well as their cell phones. Their recordings were also deleted.

The district head later called the territorial gendarmerie, a few meters from the office, whose agents came to pick up the journalists and took them to Lomé. The journalists were taken to the Territorial Brigade of the National Gendarmerie in the capital, Lomé, where they underwent three hours of interrogation before being released.

All of the main media organisations in Togo denounce the arrest of three journalists. For media organisations, in particular, the OTM, the CONAPP, the PPT, the ATOPPEL, the URATEL, the UJIT and the SYNJIT, “this attitude of the Golfe district head seriously harms the freedom to inform and condemns with the utmost rigor this aggression on journalists in the exercise of their profession.”

They recalled that under Togo’s constitution, “no one has the right to restrict” freedom of expression, considered “an essential pillar of democracy, by hiding behind any pretext whatsoever”.

They therefore called on the Togolese authorities to “do everything in their power to guarantee media professionals the free exercise of their profession”.

This act of the district head worries journalists who are recently confronted with the aggressiveness of the security forces and serial, disproportionate sanctions by the media regulator and the Court for the least error or misunderstanding.

The arrest of the three journalists comes 19 days after the license of the L’Indépendant Express newspaper was withdrawn and its publication banned indefinitely. The ban ordered by the media regulator. The request was made following the publication of an article in which the said newspaper had accused some women ministers of stealing golden spoons during a reception, an article which earned the editor of the newspaper, Carlos Komlanvi Ketohou, three days in detention.

The Media Foundation for West Africa strongly condemns the arrest of journalists Charles Kponwadan, Anani Vidzraku and Romuald Lansou, and calls on the Togolese authorities to change attitudes towards journalists. The summons of chief Dagban-Ayivon for his criticisms of the government and the interrogation of the journalists demonstrate a will to silence critics, which violates article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of which Togo is signatory.

World Radio Day 2021: MFWA Applauds the Resilience, Versatility of Radio in the Face of COVID-19

The theme for this year’s World Radio Day – New World, New Radio – highlights and celebrates the significance and resilience of radio in remaining sustainable over time; adapting to new technologies and continually providing services to society in the face of a changing world.

In West Africa, the Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) acknowledges the crucial role of radio as the most accessible media platform and source of information to citizens, especially the vulnerable, literate/semi-literate and those in remote areas. Radio has enabled information dissemination, public education, citizens’ mobilisation, sensitization and awareness creation be it in the context of conflicts, disease outbreak, terrorists’ actions and even under oppressive regimes. Significantly, within the democratisation processes of the West Africa region, radio has provided spaces for public discourse/debates and civic engagements.

With the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic, many radio newsrooms across the region evolved. Indeed, the media are faced with significant financial crisis due to advertising squeeze, less spending by media consumers and some repressive policies by governments exacerbating the already precarious sustainability crisis that confronts the region’s media. For example, in Mauritania, of the five private radio stations in the country, only one was able to stay afloat and broadcast in the whole of 2020 due to COVID-19 while in Guinea, several other journalists were laid off and other media outlets shutdown completely.

The MFWA, more importantly, applauds the resilience of radio stations in the region for adapting and developing innovative approaches to remain relevant and connected to their audiences. For instance, in Burkina Faso, WhatsApp was a major game changer. Radio stations relied on WhatsApp for newsroom meetings and decisions on topics for news programming and interviews and even for interactive programmes. In Senegal and Ghana, media organisations significantly relied the online app, ZOOM, to carry out newsroom meetings and conduct interviews. Old newsroom schedules and practices have been altered as many newsrooms run shift and allow their Journalists to file stories from home and send via mail to radio without having to go to the studio.

The growing cancellation of advertising contracts also saw many radio stations, last year, turning to the online space as a new revenue model. Senegal’s foremost private radio, SUD FM consciously boosted its online presence as part of its strategy to generate resources in the long term. According to Baye Omar, General Manager of Sud FM “the future is online and we are betting on YouTube. Now our interviews with high officials and main programmes are on YouTube. We are counting on it to generate revenues on the long term. This pandemic is offering an opportunity for radio stations go digital”.

The MFWA also commends the radio fraternity for developing new programmes focusing on COVID-19 and stepping up public education, sensitization and awareness on the pandemic. While fake news, mis/disinformation characterized COVID-19 especially on social media, several radio stations positioned themselves as a trusted and credible source of information on COVID-19. Radio enabled the vulnerable, less privileged, and citizens in remote areas citizens including the socially excluded to still access information in languages they could better understand to guide their decisions. In Ghana, for example, the MFWA’s partnership with Media Alliance against COVID-19 misinformation saw about 10 million Ghanaians reached with fact-checked information/reports to counter the fake news mis/disinformation on COVID-19. In Guinea Conakry, Radio Djigui and other radio stations in the country developed series of interactive programmes to specifically debunk false information on the pandemic.

As the world continues to battle the pandemic, the MFWA urges radio workers to strive at all times to remain professional in the discharge of their duties; remain committed to the fight against fake news dis/misinformation on COVID-19 and continue to be resolute in the enterprise of democratic governance which include holding duty bearers accountable, ensuring equitable distribution of resources and participatory governance.

Togo: Regulator Suspends L’Alternative Newspaper

The High Authority for Audiovisual and Communication (HAAC) has suspended for a period of 4 months the bi-weekly L’Alternative, accusing it of publishing false information about the Minister of Town Planning, Housing and Land Reform, Kofi Tsolenyanu, whom it called the “government’s forger.”

L’Alternative had accused the Minister of forging documents in its February 2, 2021 edition. Following this publication, the HAAC summoned the Director of publications of the newspaper, Ferdinand Messan Ayité, upon a complaint from the minister.

In a press release issued on February 5, 2021 the HAAC accused L’Alternative and its editor, Ferdinand Messan Ayité, of publishing defamatory material against the plaintiff, the Minister of Urban Planning, Housing and Land Reform. It condemned the newspaper for what it termed the publication of false information, violation of ethical rules, failure to cross-check facts and “unfounded innuendos”, that is alleging without proof.

In its statement, the HAAC claims to have asked the newspaper to “rectify the remarks made” about the member of the government, but to no avail, since, according to the HAAC, the journalist could not provide any evidence.

The newspaper’s director of publications, Ferdinand Messan Ayité, however states the contrary. “This is a report that was done with the greatest professionalism,” he maintains. “We were asked to repudiate it to please the complaining minister. We said we will not repudiate anything because everything we said is based on credible material backed with evidence,” Ayite concluded.

For some time now, the HAAC, the media regulatory body in Togo, has distinguished itself with sanctions against the press deemed “severe” and “disproportionate.”

In January, it withdrew the license of L’Indépendant Express, which wrote an article accusing four female government ministers of stealing golden spoons at a reception organised by a financial institution.

In a March 23, 2020 press release, the HAAC announced it has suspended L’Alternative and Liberté for two months and 15 days respectively for publishing articles accusing a French diplomat of meddling in Togo’s affairs.

Following the sanctions, another newspaper, Fraternité, criticized the regulator’s decision as “overzealous.” In response, the regulatory body suspended the weekly newspaper for two months on March 30, 2020.

The MFWA is very concerned about the suspension of the newspaper L’Alternative by the HAAC and urges the regulator to reconsider its decision. Suspension of newspapers affect the livelihood of many media workers and deny readers to right to information. Such sanctions, must, therefore not become the weapon of choice for the HAAC it currently appears to be. We also urge the media to focus on the facts and be ready and able to justify claims that tend to harm other people’s reputation.

Journalist, Activist Detained as Police Censor Criticism of Schools Closure

The authorities in Guinea Bissau must probe the attack by security forces on Souleymane Seidy, a journalist with the private Bombolom FM radio station, and civil society activist Franique Da Silva and ensure that the assailants are brought to book.

Souleymane Seidy was, on January 28, 2021, assaulted by the police while he was interviewing protesters who were demanding that the government rescinds its decision to close all schools in the country. The decision was taken as part of COVID-19 control measures.  Several hundreds of students and other citizens gathered in the Chapa de Bissau commercial district in the morning of January 28 to denounce the measure. They were dispersed with tear gas canisters by the security forces.

A civil society activist and a leading figure in the protest, Franique Da Silva, was also brutalised by the police who had warned him to stay away from the protests.  Seidy and Da Silva were both taken away by the police to the Segunda Esquadra prison in Bissau and detained for five and eight hours respectively. The day before the protest, the two had participated in an interactive broadcast on Bombolom FM radio and criticised the one-month suspension of public and private schools in the country as unnecessary.

This incident comes 17 days after Baducaram Imbenque, a sports journalist with the state-owned Television Guinea-Bissau (TGB), was summarily suspended from work.  In a letter dated January 11, 2021, the director of the public broadcaster, Amadú Djamanca, simply suspended the journalists indefinitely without giving any reason.

The victim told the MFWA his last assignment was the coverage of a friendly football match between the Executive and Legislature, and that he could not remember any act of misconduct or indiscretion to which he could link his suspension.

President of the Republic, Umaro Cissoko Embaló, acted as the referee in match played at the Lino Correia stadium in Bissau. It is widely believed that Imbenque was suspended because he was thought to have snubbed the President by excluding him from his post-match interviews.

When contacted to corroborate the information, the director of Television Guinea-Bissau, Amadú Djamanca, promised to react “when possible.”

Press freedom and freedom of expression in Guinea Bissau have come under siege in recent times. In August 2020, a critical blogger, Danilson Ferreira, was arrested, beaten up and thrown into the cells of the Judicial Police for a week, forcing him to flee to Lisbon, Portugal upon his release.

On the night of October 6, 2020, a group of unidentified armed men picked up Kéba Sané and Carlos Sambou, two critical bloggers who reported that their captors were led by Trcherno Bari, the head of President Umaro Sissoco’s security.

Following these incidents, a Bissau-Guinean lawyer and human rights activist, Souleymane Gassama, complained that “the state continues to flout the rules guaranteeing freedom of the press and of expression, to the point of compromising the democratic rule of law.”

The Media Foundation for West Africa (MFWA) condemns these acts of aggression and repression against press freedom and freedom of expression in Guinea Bissau and demand a probe into the recent violations against journalist Seidy and activist Da Silva. We also call on the Management of TGB to recall Imbeque to work. The media and civil society are government’s allies in the fight against corruption and efforts at promoting good governance. We, therefore, urge the authorities in Guinea Bissau to act to end the trend of repression against journalists, and activists.